King
Full Fledged Farker
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2009
- Location
- O'Fallon, MO
An excellent tutorial on how to cook indirect using the Minion Method (although like J_Don and Pappy, I always leave the top vent open), but I disagree with the assumption that it's the way to grill everything. I often use this technique for bone-in poultry, roasts, some vegetables, meatloaf, and sometimes brats. But for steaks, burgers, chops, and hot dogs, I cook direct. I vary the temperature depending on the food (direct high for steaks, direct medium for burgers and dogs, etc.), but except for extra thick steaks, which I finish indirect, the meat is over the fire the whole time. I get good grill marks with a steel cooking grate and no butter or oil. I've been doing this a long time and people seem to think I do it well; I'm always asked to do the grilling at neighborhood and family gatherings.
Arthur, I'm sure you're an expert using the grill and I would guess you get excellent results. I just wanted to point out that there are a lot of us who get good results over a direct fire and wouldn't dream of cooking a porterhouse steak indirect at 375.:wink:
I never said it's they only way to grill everything, it's one of many ways to grill indirectly and it's my personal favorite way of indirect grilling. Steaks are cooked directly over the heat, which is not the purpose of this tutorial.
As I mentioned before...enthusiasts such as ourselves don't need this setup. Try explaining the minion method, direct high, direct medium or only do this for direct and only that for indirect to a newbie. That is a lot of info to take in.
I think every newbie would benefit from knowing both direct and indirect grilling, but a few may not know about the indirect method. I understand that every method or technique is debatable, but we all got started doing one of them. I figure, if a newbie has some success doing this, then they would learn the many other ways (maybe even the correct way...:becky of grilling and give confidence to try smoking.