I will say this. Franklin's book is most definitely one of my favorites. However, I have about 150 BBQ books, and I am not ready yet to declare his my "favorite of all times". But, I would recommend it to anyone.
You know, I had thought about the question "What makes Aaron Franklin's brisket better than yours (or mine)?". From a scientific standpoint, I or anyone else should be able to apply the same simple ingredients he does, use the same methods he does, cook it to the same level of "done" as he does, and turn out a brisket identical to his. If there is nothing secretive about his briskets, why are they so much better?
It must have a lot to do with what you mention in the OP.
The videos I've seen of the guy make him seem very likable and I'm sure he makes an impressive brisket. I'll have to check the book out.
I think the biggest thing that I have gotten from his book, is that if you are truely passionate about bbq, you can learn how to make some phenomenal and truely memorable bbq.
Yeah, i am kind of a book freak.Just out of curiosity, which would you say are your top 3 or 4? This is by far the best one I've read but I haven't got close to 150. lol
Yeah, i am kind of a book freak.
I still have about 1500 books in my home library, and I reduced it a lot when we moved a few years ago.
Currently, I do put Franklin's book in my top three or four.
I would include "Smokestack Lightening" by Lois Eric Elie (a classic), "Serious Barbecue" by Adam Perry Lang, "Uncle Biilly's Downeast Barbeque Book" by Jonathan St. Laurent. This last one is an obscure one, but it is one of the more philosophical ones, chronicles a professional chef's journey from classical cooking to owning a bbq joint in Portland Maine. I do not think it is in print now.
Also I always liked anything by Dr. BBQ, Ray Lampe.
I agree about reading the real book. Unfortunately , at the present I am reduced to mostly reading on my computer or a tablet, due to a serious issue with my eyesight.Yeah I just ordered Serious BBQ after reading so many crazy good reviews. :clap2: I love BBQ books, but one thing I have discovered is that I cannot read them on the iPad. I need the actual books.
I am 100% positive that there are people on this forum and people not on this forum that can cook a brisket that is as good or if not better than Aaron Franklin. When I say that, I am not trying to take away from Franklins skills on the pit, but kind of want to make a point.
What really separates Aaron Franklin from many of the great backyard cooks is the level of his consistency and the need for that consistency on such a large cook basis. The average backyard cook has to cook 1-4 briskets perfectly for his gathering which is every so often. Franklin is cooking 1800+lbs of brisket a day. His reputation is based on the cooking the 1800+lbs of brisket perfectly. All day. Everyday. That is what separates him from everybody else.
His book is great and I like that he goes in depth about his philosophy of cooking bbq. You can feel his passion jumping out of the pages and he wants to share that same passion and intensity to anybody that is interested. And to be honest I think the biggest thing that I have gotten from his book, is that if you are truely passionate about bbq, you can learn how to make some phenomenal and truely memorable bbq.
For sure, and I hope I didn't come across as suggesting that Franklin's is overrated or anything, as I don't think that is the case.
It is more an open-ended question meant to foster discussion rather than arrive at a definitive answer. No doubt his 1,800 pounds of consistently good brisket per day is a major reason he is what he is now, but at some point he, too, was cooking 1-4 briskets at a time. How did those get good enough to take it to grow to where he is now? Why did he think he had something bigger waiting for him if he took those 4 briskets to the next step? Were people already praising him or did he just have the confidence on his own?
Questions that I'm sure are answered or alluded to in the book. I'll have to get me a copy, now.
My favorite part about the guy is that he holds very few secrets and his method is so basic.