What is your favorite Mayonnaise?

[BruceB]

Dukes or Hellman's...never tried or seen Blue Plate.

 

[food4thot]

Generally always have Duke's, or trying something else- then back to Duke's. I usually buy small containers and always arrive at best by and used by dates while quite a bit remains in the jar. Sugar versus No Sugar, type of oil that always appears first on ingredients label is something I need to pay attention too
(link to healthy mayonnaise choices)

6 Healthiest Mayonnaises of 2024 (Nutritionist-Reviewed)

Gone are the days of low-fat everything. Full-fat products are back, and as a result, mayonnaise is having a bit of a moment. But we’re a little more conscious now when it comes to the mayonnaise that we’re eating. Luckily, a number of healthy options have risen to cater to our needs.With so...

us.my-best.com

ATTST- Duke's, usually but I enjoy trying others. Next up Sir Kensington and Primal based on what they don't include in their ingredients listing.

Fun fact: wife makes a Mayonnaise Cake that uses Miracle Whip. Sometimes I'll sneak a bread slice worth and make a bologna sandwich. Try a bologna sandwich, miracle whip -on white with crushed Fritos or Lays..poor man's lettuce. About one a year or 18 months

Duke's for poll purposes. But I'm not 100% faithful to the brand

Big fan of Sir Kensington's. Other mayo's are okay. Detest MW...too sweet.

 

[16Adams]

Five more for Duke's Mayo

Link to an Allrecipes article on chef selection of Mayo.about a 30 second read

I Asked 5 Chefs to Name Their Favorite Mayo, and They All Chose the Same Brand

When it comes to store-bought mayonnaise, everyone has their favorite, including chefs. We asked five chefs to name their favorite mayo and share their top ways to use it.

www.allrecipes.com

What attracted me to Duke's was the taste and texture what has kept me with Duke's is zero sugar. But as one chef mentioned he does use others too.

But listen, if you make me a sandwich with Hellmann's, Kraft whatever I'm going to be grateful and happy.

Analogy
Duke's has a following in Mayonnaise circles like Hatch New Mexico does with green chile.

History

 

[Gnarlbecue]

Blue Plate or Best Foods. I like that they are a tiny bit sweet. I find Miracle Whip to be waaay too sweet, and Dukes is too sour. If I want it tangy or sour, I just add pickles or mustard.

 

[SweetHeatBBQnSC]

I always have Duke's and MW on hand too. Dukes is the best mayo, and MW for all salads and deviled eggs. However, like was previously mentioned MW is delicious on a Bologna sandwich. Fried or plain.

 

[Happy Hapgood]

Starting to look like Duke's in a land slide!

 

[16Adams]

Starting to look like Duke's in a land slide!

Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to pause and reflect.” Mark Twain


Well,dam

 

[K80Shooter]

It looks like I'm in the minority.

Blue Plate for me, Hellman's in a pinch.

 

[Markov]

McCormick's Mayonesa is my first choice. Although it's lime, it doesn't really taste of lime, just a citrus substitute for lemon that others use. It is also the closest to extra heavy mayo that is usually only available in restaurant sizes.

 

[frognot]

A lovely young lady that I worked with from The 'Sip introduced me to Blue Plate and converted me from Dukes.

 

[WilliamKY]

Dukes is my favorite but it's getting pricey. I like Blue Plate too and Kroger had a sale today 2/$7.00 for 30oz jars. I couldn't pass that up.

 

[Itsdone]

Im surprised nobody has tried "Heavy" Mayo. Or mentioned Heavy Mayo. I hate grocery store Kraft Mayo, but their Extra Heavy mayo is freaking delicious. Sysco Heavy mayo is my favorite, but its hard to get, there is a lot of other brands i have not tried from places like RD and The restaurant store.

Kraft now calls their Heavy mayo "deluxe" You can buy a gallon for $16 at RD.
RD also sells Hellmans 1 gallon Extra Heavy mayo for $21 at RD. Probably better then any mayo on this list.

 

[GammaRei]

MIRACLE WHIP ISNT MAYO~!!!

That being said. I use Hellmans/Best Foods, its really what I am used to and always has been consistent. My wife likes Kewpie, but thats her peoples brand (Japan). Mayo is one of my favorite condiments, I always have my hotdogs with mayo and chopped onions (sometimes with shredded cheddar as well).

- G

 

[Biloxidman]

Blue Plate all the way. Grew up with Mama using it. Tried others but always come back to BP.

 

[Happy Hapgood]

Yes, I think Blue Plate is big in the deep South.

 

[TuscaloosaQ]

Tell us why you like another brand and which one.

Bama!!!! You know that!!!