Stick Burner Help

Mlhunter

Got Wood.
Joined
Aug 3, 2015
Location
Moses...
I’m thinking about buying a stick burner trailer. I’d be moving from gravity feed and pellets cookers so I hope this is a good fit.

I don’t want to wait forever to get the smoker.

I live in Washington state so shipping in an issue.

I’m not sure if I want an offset or reverse flow smoker.
I have looked at the following smokers.

Meadow Creek – I like the idea of adding the chicken cooker. Dealer 300 miles away. Might save money.

Lone Star Grillz – looks amazing lots of different options to upgrade. If finished in time a friend might to be able to bring back from Texas.

Outlaw Smokers – seems like the Cadillac model. Enclosed Hybrid Model looks amazing. I tow it but still store in my shop. It is a lot shorten than most trailer smokers. Shipping is going to hurt.

I’m I crazy? Should I just stick with my other smokers?

Any advise? I’ve never seen any of the smokers in person, just on the internet.

Thanks
 
You say you don't want to wait forever to get the smoker. How long is too long? It took a few months to get mine and IIRC people here are ~3 months from placing the order to the construction start date - I believe that's for smokers that may take less time than a trailer. I'd recommend calling or emailing them and finding out how long your wait would be.

I've had a bit of a learning curve with mine coming from a WSM and BGE. Nothing insurmountable, I'm just happy I didn't do a big prime brisket as one of the first few cooks.
 
Stickburners are amazing and a lot of fun, but there are certainly days where it's nice to have a charcoal smoker so I don't have to feed it all night long.

Meadow Creek makes some quality stuff, but I just can't get over their sky-high prices. And they are especially high priced when you start looking at the trailer version of their smokers.

Lonestar Grills appears to make some nice stuff, but again, once you get into the trailer models it seems to get more expensive than some of the other builders out there.

You might want to look into Johnson Smokers as their trailer rigs are solid, but they aren't overpriced. I had their "Ultimate Chargrill Trailer" and it's still the best smoker I've ever had in my life. I bought it for my BBQ food trailer business and I used it for the first 6 months or so. The only problem was that it didn't have enough capacity as my business grew really quickly, so I had to find another cooker quickly!

www.johnsonsmokers.com If I had the money and was buying a new smoker today this is probably what I would have bought.

https://johnsonsmokers.com/med-6-ft/

I've never really felt like the warming boxes / cabinets were very useful...just in my opinion. For keeping the food warm I use Cambro's and I feel like it works better anyways. That 6' medium cooker is a 30" x 84" reverse flow smoker with an absolute TON of cooking space.

Last time I checked Chad Johnson was about 3 months out in terms from when you place the order until your smoker is ready, but I'm sure that fluctuates all the time. If you do plan on going with Johnson I would request a single door with counterweights rather than double doors. And I would also request that the racks span the entire width of the smoke chamber; that is that you'll have 1 upper rack and 1 lower rack, rather than 2 of each. Just having that split between the doors and the racks actually steals a bunch of cooking space when you start cooking large meats. It also makes it much more difficult to cook whole animals if that's something you would ever want to do.

Couple notes on reverse flow versus traditional flow; this will be in general as not every smoker functions the same way.

Traditional Flow : will usually have a hot zone near the firebox side, and an even spot in the middle, and then cold spots near the exhaust. You can use this to your advantage and cook your larger meats nearer the hot spots and your smaller or thinner meats in other spots. This would also allow you to do something like cook chicken close to the firebox while doing briskets in the middle at a lower temperature. The big drawback here is that you'll usually need to rotate your meat as all the heat when doing a long cook.

Reverse Flow : If done properly the entire cooking rack (from left to right) should be an even temperature. On my 60" Johnson Smoker I was usually within 5° from left to right when I was cooking. The upper racks were usually 15-20° hotter than the bottom racks, but were still even from left to right. This allowed me to load that smoker up and not worry about rotating meat or turning meat as there were no hot spots.

Good luck moving forward and there's tons of great pitbuilders out there. I don't know of any in the pacific northwest though, so you're going to end up paying for shipping. I would still wager that if you do some good research, even with shipping costs, you can get a cooker the same size (or bigger) than Meadow Creeks prices.

Something to look into for shipping are companies like www.uship.com I was able to get my smoker shipped from Texas to North Carolina for about $700. It was a trip of about 1200 miles, and you're about 2000 miles from most of the Texas pitbuilders. So that might help you in estimating what kind of shipping costs you'd be looking at.
 
I'd keep the Gravity Fed too - Everyone should have both a Stickburner And a Charcoal Smoker

https://katbbqsmokers.com

https://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/showthread.php?t=251798

https://fatstacksmokers.com/

Smitty has the right idea here in my opinion.

I LOVE stick burners, but they are not for everyone. You might consider finding a used one nearby to you and playing with it a but to see if you like offsets. But don't start with a cheap big box store one you will hate it.
 
Thanks for the feedback.

I'll always keep my MMS-G33 and Yoder YS-640. I love those smokers.

I do need a smoker for my second home that we sometime rental out as vacation rental.

I'm having a hard time pulling the trigger on a smoker like Outlaw Smoker enclosed trailer. The money is a lot and changing the stick burner.
 
I'd get a shipping quote from LSG. They seem to have the lowest shipping costs. They also OVER crate so damage should not be a concern. Those new 20" cookers are priced nicely and will fit a decent amount of meat.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk
 
I'd get a shipping quote from LSG. They seem to have the lowest shipping costs. They also OVER crate so damage should not be a concern. Those new 20" cookers are priced nicely and will fit a decent amount of meat.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

FME the "overcrating" is an understatement.
 
Back
Top