My basic question is--"Is it OK and fair to the other teams for a team with Pro experience go to BackYard and compete"???
Let me take a stab at this as a guy who's only competed in the backyard thusfar.....
I did a backyard in ribs last year. This year, I'm teaming up with another brethren and we'll compete as a pro team together. He's competed for 2 years on his own. I actually cooked with him last year twice, but only as an extra set of hands. I knew his plan (recipes, techniques, etc), but only because I asked and he told me. In the event that I cooked in the backyard, I was helping him out on his pro team, but had my UDS in his camp and had also entered in the backyard myself for ribs.
I ended up winning the BY ribs comp.
NOW....I've never really thought about this until reading this thread and how it may have looked......but.....
I entered honestly. At the time of that comp, I'd only visited teams at 2 other comps and helped Jimmy out at one other comp. Literally was just an extra set of hands.....not a cook, per se. I entered the backyard with my own recipe, my own plan, my own cooker, my own rub, sauce, etc. Used all my own supplies even. I was a legitimate backyard competitor.
BUT....since I cooked in Jimmy's camp, I wonder if the other backyard guys may have thought I was part of a pro team?
In answer to Tim's original question, I don't know if it should be allowed or not, but I don't think it's FAIR or COOL. If I had gotten beat out by a pro team who was cooking in the backyard, I'd have thought it BS. (only thing is.....did the other guys think that's exactly what I did?) The backyard is (IMHO) for guys just like me. I'd visited and hung out with a few teams, and thought I was a pretty good cook, but this was the very first time I'd put MY ribs to any kind of a real test. I wanted to see how they stood up. If I wanted to put them up against legit pro teams, I'd have entered as a pro cook. So, to me....the INTENT of the B.Y. is to have it be for "noobs".
A lot of folks on here are pro (sanctioned:roll
competitors. Just thought I'd put in a viewpoint from an actual backyard competitor.
My opinion.....