Was yours chewy? I just did my first (in another post) and found it almost gummy. But I pulled mine a little earlier. I need to follow your directions.
I've never had an issue with chewy TrI tip but I'm from ca and tri tip is nothing new to us, we cook tri tip daily around here. Something I learned on here though us cutting it against the grain will get the best results and if u cut with the grain some people get chewy tri tip out of it. Someone on here gave me this diagram showing me the proper way to cut a tri tip.
Awesome cook. Now don't buy any more. You are driving my prices up....
Gotta agree with Marty. :wink: Seems like tri-tip prices just keep going up. I'm almost tempted to start a campaign of disinformation to try to reduce demand and prices.
But unfortunately I think the word is out for good...
Since reading this post and the fact that it makes my mouth water, I've found tri-tips at Trader Joe's and plan on it being a Mother's day cook on the Weber kettle.
I agree that the next day it isn't as good. FWIW I have found that if you take what you have left over, toss it in the fridge over night, and then slice it super thin with a deli slicer, it makes some of the most awesome sandwiches ever.
but if i cook the tri tip to medium rare and slice leftovers the next day wont eating that make me sick?
what i do is cook leftovers again so theres no pink and eat, but doesnt taste nearly as good. im thinking maybe i can grind leftovers and grill for hamburgers.