Cooking Class Sledneck rib slicing success

[ique]

I understand judge 6 cant score it for taste and tenderness but appearance is appearance. The other 5 got to look at it and judge it.

I agree with this. All 6 judges can fairly assess the appearance. One judge cannot assess taste and tenderness. A better scoring would be 9,1,1 for judge 6 that did not get a sample, with the other 5 judges scoring as normal. I think this is more in line with the offense.

 

[Sledneck]

I agree with this. All 6 judges can fairly assess the appearance. One judge cannot assess taste and tenderness. A better scoring would be 9,1,1 for judge 6 that did not get a sample, with the other 5 judges scoring as normal. I think this is more in line with the offense.

are you saying you would of given me a 9 in appearance?:mrgreen:

 

[ique]

are you saying you would of given me a 9 in appearance?:mrgreen:

I was more just trying to make my point. :razz:

But 8 or maybe 9.

 

[Fatback Joe]

I had given him a 4 so the drop to a 1 wasn't that big of a deal.

Don't let the picture fool you.

 

[Jacked UP BBQ]

for the love of bbq!

 

[deguerre]

I had given him a 4 so the drop to a 1 wasn't that big of a deal.

Don't let the picture fool you.

Well, natch. We ARE talking about Sled, right?

 

[Muzzlebrake]

I agree with this. All 6 judges can fairly assess the appearance. One judge cannot assess taste and tenderness. A better scoring would be 9,1,1 for judge 6 that did not get a sample, with the other 5 judges scoring as normal. I think this is more in line with the offense.

thats a fair point. Keep coming up with these sensible ideas and your name may end up on Scottie and Todd's radar for BoD candidates

 

[boogiesnap]

I agree with this. All 6 judges can fairly assess the appearance. One judge cannot assess taste and tenderness. A better scoring would be 9,1,1 for judge 6 that did not get a sample, with the other 5 judges scoring as normal. I think this is more in line with the offense.

exactly my point.

el corazon 2013!!!

 

[HarleyGirl14226]

thats a fair point. Keep coming up with these sensible ideas and your name may end up on Scottie and Todd's radar for BoD candidates

I second that! :biggrin1:

 

[Sledneck]

Appearance pfffT. Boogiesnap can verify this. I thought my chicken was the fuggliest ive ever turned in. I got (6) 9s,.

 

[Sledneck]

somebody told be there was a table with only 5 judges. if I ended up on that table would my ribs have passed?

 

[boogiesnap]

i don't think so because that is not the rule as written( six portions), but would be interesting to know how it would've been handled.

 

[smokincracker]

Had i been judging i would of shook it :-?

Did you say Shook it???

 

[Fatback Joe]

Stop worrying about it. I had a brisket that tasted like A1 and it was damn good.

somebody told be there was a table with only 5 judges. if I ended up on that table would my ribs have passed?

 

[timzcardz]

Hmmmm . . .

Sledneck recent words of wisdom on on knife sharpening:

Depends on what quality of knife your sharpening . I started buying those black handle restaurant depot knives that are $8. They getnme through at least 2 contests and then I chuck them. CheAper than sharpenng

(Found here: http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/showthread.php?t=140915 )

 

[Sledneck]

E

Did you say Shook it???

Sure did! Is is not in the crackerese dictionary?

 

[CBQ]

Appearance pfffT. Boogiesnap can verify this. I thought my chicken was the fuggliest ive ever turned in. I got (6) 9s,.

We were told later by a CBJ that his table had a bunch of new judges that were handing out 6s and 7s to everyone. "Hey, the sheet says 7 is above average! It's good, so let's give it a 7." Since there were only 4 tables, everyone likely got one entry hitting that table.

I think our chicken hit that table. I guess yours did not. :mrgreen:

 

[Muzzlebrake]

Appearance pfffT. Boogiesnap can verify this. I thought my chicken was the fuggliest ive ever turned in. I got (6) 9s,.

Don't sell yourself short, I've seen you turn in much uglier chicken. Good thing you're retiring

 

[ique]

thats a fair point. Keep coming up with these sensible ideas and your name may end up on Scottie and Todd's radar for BoD candidates

:runs and hides: :twitch:

 

[Nordy]

If there is a table of 5 judges... the TC typically acts as the 6th judge right?