Rate the box. :)

[BBQchef33]

Picture is a little off, but finish on these were like glass. The pieces down the center were the sides cut from the bone on 3 oversized thighs and fanned down the center. Parsley bed was even, typical putting green with minimal showing.

Please score... thanks..

 

[Garrett]

That is some tight chicken!!! 9 all dayum day long.

 

[Slamdunkpro]

From the photo the back right and front right thigh look scorched. For me the color isn't appetizing. From the picture I have to go 7.

 

[jmoney7269]

From the photo the back right and front right thigh look scorched. For me the color isn't appetizing. From the picture I have to go 7.

Good lord man, that's one of the best looking chicken boxes I have ever seen. I would love to see what you think is a 9 because I just tried to reach through the screen and snatch one up. It's BBQ, and it looks BBQ'd and yumdiddlyscrumptious

ELEVEN! Oh wait y'all only go to 9 so a TEN! Definitely a beatiful box.

 

[landarc]

Off-hand, quick glance-9

I assume that there are 6 of the cut pieces and not 5, it sort of looks like 5, which would be bad. I could drop to eight if the color is a little less even than it appears in the image.

 

[landarc]

From the photo the back right and front right thigh look scorched. For me the color isn't appetizing. From the picture I have to go 7.

You're a hard man.

 

[Rub'n Wood BBQ]

Looks great, but only 4 little ones might be an issue as there is not 6 servings.

 

[Rub'n Wood BBQ]

Oops, closer look shows 6. Nevermind, 9.

 

[BBQchef33]

From the photo the back right and front right thigh look scorched. For me the color isn't appetizing. From the picture I have to go 7.

absolutely no scorching on there at all.

 

[BBQchef33]

Off-hand, quick glance-9

I assume that there are 6 of the cut pieces and not 5, it sort of looks like 5, which would be bad. I could drop to eight if the color is a little less even than it appears in the image.

there are 6. Look close at top.. thats 2 pieces.

 

[Pitmaster T]

"Perfection is its own form of marking" Popdaddy, 1978.

 

[Mark Warren]

Looks Great to me.
Not gonna judge the Grand PooBah.

 

[Big M1ke]

I don't know a lot. But that looks damn good :thumb:

 

[BBQchef33]

Looks Great to me.
Not gonna judge the Grand PooBah.

Im a member too! :yo:

Trying to gauge if I'm nuts or the judges were drunk. Honest opinions are helpful to everyone. :thumb:


soooooo.. pick a number... 1-9. 8) any number... eenie meeny mine mo....

 

[Mark Warren]

Im a member too! :yo:

Trying to gauge if I'm nuts or the judges were drunk. Honest opinions are helpful to everyone. :thumb:

that case I have never been to a judging of any kind of food competition, so I am totally unqualified to even take a guess. But I will say I can't see anything wrong with them at all.
They look real Damn Tasty to me.

 

[Muzzlebrake]

8 from the pic, possibly a 9 in person

 

[Butt Rubb'n BBQ]

I give it a 9 as well. I am having a hard time with pieces down the middle. Just not use to seeing that and seems out of place to me. Want a shine on that chicken. Great job.

 

[Bbq Bubba]

LOTS of meat. Hardly any parsley. :wink: Beautiful color and symmetry.

9

 

[TheJackal]

My guess is that it wasn't 43rd because of appearance. If I showed you a pic of my pork box (if I had one) you'd think 22 was a screw job also. I don't think teams win or lose because of appearance scores. However, taste/tenderness anomalies always concern me. Our first place brisket got a 5 in taste from one judge (no comment card and obviously tossed out). Nice job on your 5th place Pork call.

 

[BBQ Tim]

I am having a hard time with pieces down the middle. Just not use to seeing that and seems out of place to me.

Agree with stament above, the thighs look awesome!