THE BBQ BRETHREN FORUMS

Welcome to The BBQ Brethren Community. Register a free account today to become a member and see all our content. Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Kyle Serlington

Full Fledged Farker
Joined
Jun 11, 2014
Location
Binghamton, NY
so in case you missed my introduction in the cattle call a few weeks back, i've been smoking for 5 years now, been using a WSM for the last 3 and i really like it. i can cook ribs, chicken, and butts just fine but i've been having issues with my brisket, which i've only cooked a handful of times because it's pretty expensive around here. so for the 4th of july i did a butt and a brisket and here's how they went...

i got up a little after 8am and had my smoker up to temp by 9:30. i don't season my meat overnight anymore, so as soon as i got up i trimmed and seasoned my shoulder. it was between 8 and 9lbs and there was a lot of fat that i trimmed off. smoker started out at 250 and maintained that temp pretty well all for a while

10481174_10152144344546373_2935536909516137540_n.jpg


i got a nice smoke using hickory and apple wood chunks over lump charcoal

10462903_10152144344516373_961902258369444142_n.jpg


here's the brisket. i seasoned it around 10am and put it on a little before 11. it was just a flat that i bought at wal-mart for $7 per pound. this is the last time i buy a flat from them, it was about 4.75lbs and the bottom of the package was black so i couldn't see how much fat was on it. if you look at the top left corner you'll see that it's a very thin flap which was hidden in the packaging. the top right corner was very similar, although the picture makes it hard to tell


10525707_10152144344636373_74524515512248900_n.jpg


i had intended on taking the meat off at 6pm and letting it rest, then serve dinner at 7. by 4:30 it wasn't where i wanted it to be temp wise. pork was stalling at 165 and the brisket was stalling at about 175, so i ended up wrapping them in foil. at this point i had ran out of charcoal and the temp on my smoker was dipping below 200 so i decided to throw them in the oven for the rest of the cook. by 6:30 the brisket was at 195 and it was a little tough when i probed it but not too bad so i decided to take it off and let it rest. the pork was done 20 minutes later.

603631_10152144344796373_21912464785865024_n.jpg


i feel the pork looks a little dry in this pic but that wasn't the case, it was actually very moist and most of the fat had rendered out, i only had to throw out a couple little pieces.

10456825_10152144344876373_5294679462863097449_n.jpg


and there's the brisket. in my opinion it was dry but everyone kept telling me it was fine. if i was at a restaurant and served brisket like this i wouldn't have been too happy. flavor was good but even though it was cooking in a pan in its own juices it still came out dry! i'm gunna have to blame the cut of meat on this one. i really didn't want to spend the extra time doing a whole packer but next time i'm just going to have to try it because flats just don't seem to be cutting it for me.

10485366_10152144345111373_1909991417827929138_n.jpg


the final plate. all homemade. i did a brown sugar bbq sauce for the pork and for the brisket i did a white sugar sauce that's almost like a BBQ salsa.

and then the rest of the night we had fun playing Stump and lighting off fireworks

10338225_10152144345876373_8694053402549922579_n.jpg


10484228_10152144346866373_3922524756631129417_n.jpg


10502473_10152144347451373_2541671995149492447_n.jpg


10524341_10152144347291373_5915068563943959752_n.jpg


10494602_10152144348076373_6967915416643236714_n.jpg
 
Looks like it was a great day and cook. At $7 for brisket, I can understand why you don't get a lot of practice in. Welcome to the forum.
 
Welcome to the forum! Looks like a great time. Also looks like you nailed the food. Very nice!
 
BBQ is about bringing people together and time spent with friends and family. Five years from now they won't remember the moisture content of the brisket but they will remember the good food and hospitality. Nice post.
 
Looks like a Great time Brisket is expensive everywhere these days I just got some BB Ribs that were really high 6.99 per lb
 
Flats and half-flats can be tough to get right. I learned on packers after messing up some flats, but I'm not convinced that necessarily helped me--I messed up packers too.

In general, dry and tough means undercooked brisket. Dry and crumbly means overcooked brisket. But with a flat in general, it can be tough to get moisture in there whether it's attached to a point or not.

Two things you can do:

1. If you're cooking USDA Select, try stepping up to Choice.
2. Inject.

I've switched to doing #2 pretty much all the time, especially if it's a Select brisket. I use Butcher BBQ Prime injection, but you can just inject straight up beef broth, or a broth/worcestershire mixture, or pretty much anything else you can dream up. The key is that with added liquid in the middle of the meat, more of it is retained as the protein fibers contract and squeeze out water.
 
yeah i was considering an injection or marinade next time. i know about the tough vs crumbly brisket, but the thing is that it was so uneven that only some parts crumbled! i'm not buying another piece of beef with half black packaging ever again haha. the weird thing is that i passed up a whole packer that was only like a dollar more than the flat, i guess i should just get one of those and spend more time on it. as for this weekend, i think i'm gunna do some ribs and chicken, i have a lot of leftover sauce to use up
 
Back
Top