All I have to compare my Evie Mae's to is Dylan's Austin Smoke Works (same as a Moberg) from that one day. I think the direct flow cooks a bit faster and you lose a little real estate on the firebox end of a direct flow. Other than that they are similar in my opinion. Both draft like crazy, fire management is the same on both, stupid simple. No coal baskets or ash pans to mess with. Both have heavy insulation. Mine is so well insulated I have trouble trying to shut things down. I would assume Moberg is the same. My coal bed can remain for hours even when I try to choke it all out.
If you flipped a coin Moberg vs Evie Mae's, I don't you would be disappointed either way.
There's a place in Houston called Reveille Barbecue Company that uses a Evie Mae's 500 gallon reverse flow. One of the owner's named James McFarland used to work at Tejas where they use Moberg. So he has experience with both. Maybe chat with him if you're on the fence and have questions. I talked him a bit on one of my visits about what he liked better. He said he prefers the Moberg but nothing wrong with the Evie Mae's, it's just different.
pitmaster@reveillebbq.com
https://www.instagram.com/reveillebbq
I put a deposit on a 250 Moberg the same time I put one on my Evie Mae's. I was curious about the reverse flow, and with the giant stack I figured it has to draft as good as the Moberg. I'm now on the fence if I should get my deposit back on the Moberg. I'm still curious about them, but I just don't see it being that much better, it's just preference.