Help/Tips - Pulled Pork for 40 ???

Michigan BBQ Fan · Sep 19, 2020

Hey Brethren,

Looking for help/tips on making pulled pork for a crowd. Next weekend I'm making pulled pork for 40. It will be for a homeless shelter. I'm excited to help. I've never made anything more than a few butts for friends. This is a bit different. But here are the highlights...

1. I'm using a 18.5 WSM.
2. I need to make enough for 40 guys, how much should I make (pre-cook weight)?
3. I need to deliver it (cold) on Monday @ 6 P.M. but I'm out of town the three days before that. So, I'm looking to make it 6-7 days beforehand and keep it in the fridge. Thoughts? Do I keep it "whole" and shred it on that Monday...or...do shred and store in the fridge?

Recipe wise I'm probably going with an inject/rub/wrap similar to Chris Lilly's paths, unless anyone has any suggestions based on what works better for quantity.

THANKS for your help Brethren!

Welcome to the BBQ Revival!

TravelingJ · Sep 19, 2020

I can't answer the 6-7 days part. If you keep it whole, you'd need to reheat it to be able to shred it.

Michigan BBQ Fan · Sep 19, 2020

I was thinking that. Do you think I could/should cook it to a "lower" temp than I would normally pull it off the smoker?...and then...reheat in oven to pull?

mchar69 · Sep 19, 2020

I'd cook it, pull it, put it in 1 gallon zip locks, [maybe freeze it,
then thaw it 2 days prior] and tell them to heat it up in 190f or so water before serving. It will definitely last more than a week in your cold fridge.
I'd cook about 24 pounds pre- weight.

AUswimKC · Sep 19, 2020

mchar69 said:
I'd cook it, pull it, put it in 1 gallon zip locks, [maybe freeze it,
then thaw it 2 days prior] and tell them to heat it up in 190f or so water before serving. It will definitely last more than a week in your cold fridge.
I'd cook about 24 pounds pre- weight.

That 18” has multiple racks? I’d get four 8-9lbs butts. Two butts per rack. Butt is cheap. Might as well fill that WSM up

Mandreyka · Sep 19, 2020

30 lbs uncooked will be plenty, do them up ahead of time, shred and vacuum seal/freeze.

Just drop them off defrosted

Ron_L · Sep 19, 2020

For guys figure 8 ounces cooked, which will be generous, and figure 50% yield, so you need 1 lb. raw per person. You could go with 6 ounces cooked, 12 ounces raw and probably be fine.

As far as cooking in advance, I would pull it and vacuum seal, and then it can easily be reheated in hot water.

jzadski · Sep 20, 2020

Another for pulling and freezing. I like to error on the side of caution and go with Ron's 1lb raw per person.

Help/Tips - Pulled Pork for 40 ???

Michigan BBQ Fan

Take a breath!

TravelingJ

is One Chatty Farker

Michigan BBQ Fan

Take a breath!

mchar69

Quintessential Chatty Farker

AUswimKC

Knows what a fatty is.

Mandreyka

Knows what a fatty is.

Ron_L

Administrator

jzadski

Babbling Farker

Similar threads