Having now experienced both the GAB and the Royal now I would go with GAB if I only had a choice of 1. The Royal was fun to watch all the craziness on Friday night and maybe if I was 20 years old it would of been a blast but after that Sat and Sun turned into a ghost town. At the GAB, as mentioned by a few above is more of a cooks contest and more cooker friendly and to me was run better. The GAB had the same great vibe throughout the weekend