THE BBQ BRETHREN FORUMS

Welcome to The BBQ Brethren Community. Register a free account today to become a member and see all our content. Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Who should win the BBQ Brethren "McRib" Throwdown?


  • Total voters
    57
  • Poll closed .
That was crazy tough to decide. I decided to go with Redhot because it was so creative and looked tasty at the same time (even though it used real McRibs) and you could even SEE the actual McRib!!!:thumb:
 
By the authority vested in me as a 100% certifiable (trust me) moderator of this subforum, as granted upon me by the Grand Poohbah and the Green Force, I do hereby declare the following:

Article IV, Section Q, Paragraph 3
The original McRib poll posted for the Original McRib Throwdown will remain in effect and will remain the official result for the Throwdown. The winner of this poll will receive the prize and be declared the overall winner of all McRib entries, and therefore be crowned the McRib King/Queen of the Universe, until such a time that they are properly dethroned or they otherwise begin to disavow knowledge of said title.

Gamma Quadrant, Sector 4
After the overall winner is determined, two new polls will be posted; one for dishes containing actual McRib products, and another for dishes that do not have actual McRibs in them. The winner of the overall McRib vote will not be included in these polls. These will be the consolation winners, and they will receive a consolation prize.

Down the road, First right, Third door on the left
The rest of you farkers get nothing. Nada. Zilch. Zero. You don't even get a participation trophy. Now go home and have a good cry.

:becky::becky::becky::becky:
 
{Midnight ☼ Smoke};1465352 said:
Many good looking entries on this one but I had to go with the one that seemed to be on the money with the McRib! zydecopaws really hit the mark!

Ditto. Not only did it match, but it looked good! I really want to reach out and eat it.
 
Woohoo! Other than voting I did not participate, which means I got nothing for nothing, I usually have to pay for that. I break even, and as property tax time closes in, getting nothing for doing nothing is way better than paying thousands for doing nothing. I feel like a winner already, Thanks Bigabyte :thumb:
 
Hey Ryan,
I realize I have to vote tonight if I can remember, arrrrgh! You're one of my finalists. Can you tell me those were the BEST McEggplants you've ever had or are you just trying to get a cheap and easy double zero? :thumb:
Gore
 
I'm with you on this. It's hard to compare the farcical ones with the serious ones. How about splitting this into two votes, one for those that used McRibs and one for those that didn't?

I'm pretty sure anything with EP in it would be taken in only the MOST serious way - we're dealing with a rockstar combination when EP and deep fried wheat grass are in the mix! :heh: :thumb:

Hey Ryan,
I realize I have to vote tonight if I can remember, arrrrgh! You're one of my finalists. Can you tell me those were the BEST McEggplants you've ever had or are you just trying to get a cheap and easy double zero? :thumb:
Gore

Wait a sec... I'm a finalist??? Bazaar... :crazy:
And, to be fair... yes and yes. They were the ONLY McEggplants I've ever had so by default they were the best and who would expect anything other than a double ought after pouring so much time and work into the only 2 TD entries that contain the dreaded EP??

I did it cuz I thought it would be fun(ny) and push myself to make the very best losers I could! I wanted to make them look good enough that I might get some votes, fully knowing that it wasn't likely.
Sweet Success! Wait, I prolly shouldn't count my eggplants before they hatch, should I?

Alright in all seriousness, (you're either gonna think I'm a gurly man, or think I'm still kidding around, neither are true.) The deep fried lettuce wrapped sea-urchin thingy (thanks Guerry! :wink:) was hands down the most enjoyable and most edible.
Here's why/how that's even possible:
1st the deep fried panko gave an awesome, crunchy shell and made me forget that I might be eating some sort of purple veggie-orb that was good for me (reminded me of fried zucchinni, but way bigger)

2nd the lettuce wrap gave another type of crunch that was cool in contrast to the fried EP, the english cucumbers also added a really fresh taste to the sandwich (if it's even legal to call it that).

3rd including bbq sauce was very different than what you'd expect on a creation of this sort, the salty, crunchy panko recived a bright, tangy & spicy kick.

4th (I know, tough to believe that I'm still going right?) The wheat grass, while a nod to Chris' friends, the commie pinko, camel humpin, pachouli wearin hippies, was surprisingly welcome. I expected it to taste like I was munching on the lawn clippings or something, but it didn't at all. The slight bitterness of the grass added another depth since the sauce was sweet and they played off eachother.

5th (almost done) The tempura EP fries - Holy fark those were good! I am not ashamed to proclaim that from roof tops! I could eat those suckers all day! Well, until they get cold at least, kinda soggy at that point...

6th The Eggplant itself - in both entries they were very juicy and while a soft texture, they still had a "meaty" quality to them.

As for the Bacon wrapped one, I wish I could tell everyone what they want to hear, but it just wasn't that amazing... Don't get me wrong, it tasted and smelled incredible, but the bacon and the rub made it too salty... The sweetness in the sauce all over it (and in it) helped disguise the saltiness a bit, but I could only eat half of it before my taste buds gave out on me.

Now I prolly really farked you up, cuz if I know you gore, the bacon is beckoning...
 
Can I get a couple more votes here Chris? It seems that if we were allowed more than one entry, we should get to vote more than once as well. I would like to take KnucklHed for the block please.
 
Thanks Ryan for your all-too-brief and concise answer. In actuality, I cannot vote for the first McEggplant because in my mind it is not grilled/smoked and violates the rules -- others have different feelings about this and that is fine, but that is mine. It looks delicious, yes, but I am only considering the bacon-wrapped. I would agree that the rub would make it too salty, but I never seem to complain about that even when everyone else is reaching for more water. In light of your first answer though, I will remove it from my list of finalists as we can never have enough eggplant in the Zero's Club. I wish you good luck!

Great, now only five more finalists to sift through, arrrrrgh!
 
Can I get a couple more votes here Chris? It seems that if we were allowed more than one entry, we should get to vote more than once as well. I would like to take KnucklHed for the block please.

Vote for the Eggplant thingies! For the Fun of it!


We are supposed to be having fun, right?:becky:


You farkers are going to ruin my double ought chances AND my chances for world domination!!!!
...On the other hand, maybe McD's will pick up on their popularity and start selling their EP McRibs on earth instead of only the moon... and then make me fabulously wealthy Muuahhhhh! :twisted:
 
Not having had one of these for a very long time made me think very hard. And that's not easy right now.

But I voted for "Z" cause I thought he duplicated this famed sammi in great fashion. And I truly believe that we all should be learning to like Spam. Real food could get hard to find very soon. :tape:
 
Well, I had to go with Redhot, most of all, for doing something truly special with those McRibs, actually making them into something that I would like to try. This is truly a creative and inspirational dish that I would feel proud to put at the center of my Thanksgiving table.
 
Soooo, I think the voters are either A) giving me a hard earned double zero on some great looking eggplant or B) Ya'll are a buncha sissies afraid to have yer name seen next to an EGGPLANT ENTRY!!!! :twisted::twisted:

It's not too late to make eggplant the new bacon... we could make this a landslide win if we really want to!
Think of it like this... Bacon is... bacon is the incumbent democrat running around handing out all your hard earned money to the bleeding hearts... It's also the incumbent republican claiming that they are lowering your taxes while spending more farkin money on war than ever before... Bacon is... the TSA groping your wife and child at the airport because you might be alCIAda.

Now Eggplant on the other hand, eggplant wants nothing more than to pull the rug out from under all those farks. Eggplant wants to flip the game board off the table yelling "this farkin' game sucks!!" as it climbs over the table reaching for the throats of bureaucrats that pretend to care for anyone but themselves.

Eggplant is the new FREEDOM FOOD!!! Eggplant is kicking a$$ and taking names! Eggplant isn't gonna take it any more!!
WHO'S WITH ME???!!!!! I said, WHO'S WITH ME???!!!!! RAAAAAAGGGGGHHHHHH!!!!!
 
Back
Top