• xenforo has sucessfully updated our forum software last night. Howevr, that has returned many templates to stock formats which MAY be missing some previous functionality. It has also fixed some boroken templates Ive taken offline. Reat assured, we are working on getting our templates back to normal, but will take a few days. Im working top down, so best bet is to stick with the default templates as I work thru them.

Pork Spare Ribs VS. Babybacks?

Mooner

is one Smokin' Farker
Joined
Jul 18, 2006
Messages
799
Reaction score
48
Location
Southeas...
Name or Nickame
Mooner
Hey guys, I cooked several slabs of spareribs for the North KC competition. This was my first time cooking them and needless to say I am pretty unfamiliar with them anatomy wise. They cooked up fine, color was there, and they were very tender. I had my butcher trim them up for me so they were already a STL. cut. However, when I went to cut them for my turn-in, it almost seemed like there were 2 sets of bones? I would cut where I thought in between ribs and hit bone. I pulled out a bone and there was another one to take its place. What is the deal? I always assumed that spare ribs were essentially anatomically similar to babybacks. you cut between a rib you get a rib. Why did I have so much issue with hitting bone?
 
You must of had too much of the "spare" part of the rib in the cut you were given. I cut spares to St. Louis all the time for comps. If you don't cut the proper place you can wind up with some boney ribs.
 
That's interesting because I just smoked my first St. Louis style rack yesterday.

I found the same thing - but only down at the short end of the rack. I thought the same thing - 'hey what's this spiney little bone here' - but I must admit they were delicious! I can put up with a few bones here and there for a tasty treat like that!

I have no idea what the judges would have thought - I'll bet they've seen it before . . .
 
Thats just the grissle that goes into the brisket end of that slab, you probably got it cut a little bit too large. usually if you flip them so that they are curve up - you can see a vein of fat that you can follow to cut on the inside of that extra "bony" grissle.

Once you learn to trim them its a breeze. I have to give props to Mark G. (4 Men and a Pig) - he came over to me the first year at Osage (had a shot of single barrel in hand) and told me - boy, you are trimmin' those ribs all wrong... Trim them like this <showed me on a slab> and you will get your name called. Needless to say, I did get it called.:icon_clown Trimming them right definately makes a difference.
 
Does this help?



St. Louis Spare Rib Prep

Of course you can toss a whole “packer” of spare ribs on the smoker and have plenty of good eats. The St. Louis cut on a spare rib produces a better presentation and cooks more evenly. You can see from the picture of the full packer of ribs that the there are wider and narrower parts of the rack. The wider sections are going to cook slower than the narrow. The St. Louis cut takes care of this issue.
stlouisspares%20001%20%28Custom%29.jpg

Let’s take this full rack of spare ribs and turn it into a St. Louis cut. The first step is to flip to the back and remove the skirt. We’ll keep this small piece of rib meat for beans later or a snack before the ribs are done. The skirt off of the smoker won’t be as tender as your ribs. The skirt should be done in about 3 hours.
stlouisspares%20002%20%28Custom%29.jpg

The next step of removing the membrane is optional. To leave the membrane will leave a bit of chew to the backside of the rib. Some that cook over higher heat will leave the membrane to render and crisp up. Since I cook low and slow, I like to remove the membrane. It can be tough, but will a little patience and practice the membrane removal can be accomplished. The best tip I’ve been given for removing the membrane is to use a paper towel to get a good grip. I simply us a paring knife to work up one edge of the membrane, grab with the paper towel, and pull. This process can be referred to as “skinning” the rib.
stlouisspares%20003%20%28Custom%29.jpg

Let’s start squaring this rib up to look like a traditional St. Louis style rack of ribs. You’ll notice that the rib bones don’t extend all the way accross the full rack. The top of the rack is full of cartilage, not bone. To start the St. Louis cut, follow the rib bones across the rack seperating the bones from the upper cartilage. This upper cartilage is known as the “rib tips” We can either cook these up now as snacks or save for later. Since I have a small family, one rack of St. Louis ribs will feed us well. My rib tips are saved for beans or a future smoke. They’ll get tossed in the freezer until there are several for a good feed of Rib Tips. Back to the cut, I stop with about 2-3 small ribs to go. Remember, we want a square rack, not pointed. If we left the last few small ribs, they’ be overdone by the time the rest of the rib rack was ready to eat.
stlouisspares%20005%20%28Custom%29.jpg

A flip back to the front and you can see the transformation that our packer has taken to become the legendary St. Louis Style Spare Ribs. Rubbed with some love, this rack of ribs is ready for smoke.
stlouisspares%20010%20%28Custom%29.jpg
 
awesome tutorial, thanks. I remove the membrane, cook them whole then trim em. The dogs like the "knuckles" (as we call them) cooked. But I don't do competitions.
 
That's it, I need some spares. I have not trimmed my spares before which is probably why they have been giving me fits. With this now trimmed St. Louis cut, the "3-2-1 guideline" applies correct?
 
Puppyboy said:
That's it, I need some spares. I have not trimmed my spares before which is probably why they have been giving me fits. With this now trimmed St. Louis cut, the "3-2-1 guideline" applies correct?

From my experience 3-2-1 is too long. Try 2-2-1 or 3-1-1 and experiment with what works for you.
 
Plowboy said:
From my experience 3-2-1 is too long. Try 2-2-1 or 3-1-1 and experiment with what works for you.
Agreed. Another falicy of 3-2-1 is temp.
 
Plowboy said:
From my experience 3-2-1 is too long. Try 2-2-1 or 3-1-1 and experiment with what works for you.

What you talkin about Willis?
Explain to me to me 3-2-1 or 2-2-1 or 3-1-1. :confused: I don't how to cut anything. Is there a book that explains this and other meats?
 
Great tutorial! I've tried several times to remove that membrane. It's on a bit dard to do with spare ribs, but I've given up on babybacks. Just can't seem to get it all off without spending what seems like half the day.
 
Thanks for the tips on trimming spares. I've stayed away from them and have stuck to baby backs just because I could never get them trimmed right, and they are easy to prepare foor the smoker. Membrane comes off pretty clean every time.
 
VGuilford said:
Plowboy
Do you have a tutorial on trimming a brisket?

  1. Open Cryo
  2. Inject (optional)
  3. Season
  4. Smoke
  5. Sauce (optional)
  6. Eat
Some people trim their briskets before cooking, but most don't I'd say. Fat cap up or fat cap down, there are different theories on that. I've done them both ways side by side and can't tell a whole lot of difference. I'm a fat cap up kinda guy. Now you can seperate the point after the cook and make some tasty burnt ends.

http://plowboysbbq.com/archives/164

Here's a good brisket prep tutorial. Lot's of good info. You don't have to do as much as they are doing here, but its a guide.

http://virtualweberbullet.com/brisketselect.html
 
Back
Top