Subzerogriller
Full Fledged Farker
- Joined
- May 10, 2012
- Location
- Blaine, MN
I'm still learning the comp forum, so forgive me if this post is too long-winded or just not in the right place...
Did our first comp yesterday. Had a blast! Just a small amateur comp in a small town in northern WI. Been hemming and hawing about competing for awhile, and finally got pushed hard enough by friends and family to take the jump. I'll try to post a few pics when I have time to upload.
The wife was my assistant, and for someone who has never cooked Q before, she was amazing. By halfway through the day, I didn't even need to give her direction; we were just in sync and everything ran smoother than I could have hoped. I think we may have found a new way to bond.
Comp was ribs, chicken, and sausage. I had no idea what I wanted to do for sausage, but the entry fee was so low ($15 per category) that I decided to throw a fatty in there just to see. Finished 7th out of 10. :laugh: Chicken...well, I honestly don't even know why I did chicken, I've never cooked it comp style before and only smoked it once. But we finished about middle of the pack (6 out of 13). I was pretty happy with that, all things considered. Ribs were a disappointment. First off, the "St Louis" spares I bought from Costco, still had what appeared to be the sternum bone in them. This is the second time I've had this happen, and both times I couldn't identify the bone just by looking/feeling the meat; it wasn't till I cut in that I found it. And if I'd trimmed it out, I would've had only about 1-1.5 inches of meat left. I'm not sure I'll buy spares from Costco again. Second, I lost my head at one point and forgot a fairly major piece of my flavor profile. :doh: Third, my Maverick ET-732 wasn't working properly; all it would give me was "LLL" or "HHH" for a reading. All I had to go by was my hood therm, and according to that, I never got over 260* all day, even with a full bag of charcoal and the vents wide open. All meats were done properly (or at least close) within normal timeframes though, so I guess it worked out. And I was feeling pretty good; we had people raving about our ribs, and two of the judges (out of 6) actually came and sought me out to tell me how much they enjoyed them. For a moment, I thought I might actually get a call....but I placed 9th out of 18.
I honestly didn't care if I got a call or not; by the end of the day, I was having so much fun that it didn't even matter. But now that I've caught the bug, I want to do better, so I'm wondering if anyone can offer any advice. First, am I correct in assuming that bone I found (running perpendicular to the rib bones) is the sternum? Should it really be in the middle, giving me only about an inch of meat on each side? Second, my scores varied greatly from one judge to another; is this normal, or is it just indicative of a small-town comp with judges who may or may not be qualified (keep in mind, nearly every winner was either a local or someone who had been to this comp at least 3-4 times)? Third, I've messed with a couple different sauces; one is sweeter, and one has a bit (not a lot) of heat to it. I used the hotter sauce for my turn ins; do sweeter sauces typically do better? Of course, any other tips or advice are always welcome.
Did our first comp yesterday. Had a blast! Just a small amateur comp in a small town in northern WI. Been hemming and hawing about competing for awhile, and finally got pushed hard enough by friends and family to take the jump. I'll try to post a few pics when I have time to upload.
The wife was my assistant, and for someone who has never cooked Q before, she was amazing. By halfway through the day, I didn't even need to give her direction; we were just in sync and everything ran smoother than I could have hoped. I think we may have found a new way to bond.
Comp was ribs, chicken, and sausage. I had no idea what I wanted to do for sausage, but the entry fee was so low ($15 per category) that I decided to throw a fatty in there just to see. Finished 7th out of 10. :laugh: Chicken...well, I honestly don't even know why I did chicken, I've never cooked it comp style before and only smoked it once. But we finished about middle of the pack (6 out of 13). I was pretty happy with that, all things considered. Ribs were a disappointment. First off, the "St Louis" spares I bought from Costco, still had what appeared to be the sternum bone in them. This is the second time I've had this happen, and both times I couldn't identify the bone just by looking/feeling the meat; it wasn't till I cut in that I found it. And if I'd trimmed it out, I would've had only about 1-1.5 inches of meat left. I'm not sure I'll buy spares from Costco again. Second, I lost my head at one point and forgot a fairly major piece of my flavor profile. :doh: Third, my Maverick ET-732 wasn't working properly; all it would give me was "LLL" or "HHH" for a reading. All I had to go by was my hood therm, and according to that, I never got over 260* all day, even with a full bag of charcoal and the vents wide open. All meats were done properly (or at least close) within normal timeframes though, so I guess it worked out. And I was feeling pretty good; we had people raving about our ribs, and two of the judges (out of 6) actually came and sought me out to tell me how much they enjoyed them. For a moment, I thought I might actually get a call....but I placed 9th out of 18.
I honestly didn't care if I got a call or not; by the end of the day, I was having so much fun that it didn't even matter. But now that I've caught the bug, I want to do better, so I'm wondering if anyone can offer any advice. First, am I correct in assuming that bone I found (running perpendicular to the rib bones) is the sternum? Should it really be in the middle, giving me only about an inch of meat on each side? Second, my scores varied greatly from one judge to another; is this normal, or is it just indicative of a small-town comp with judges who may or may not be qualified (keep in mind, nearly every winner was either a local or someone who had been to this comp at least 3-4 times)? Third, I've messed with a couple different sauces; one is sweeter, and one has a bit (not a lot) of heat to it. I used the hotter sauce for my turn ins; do sweeter sauces typically do better? Of course, any other tips or advice are always welcome.