Pork Butts....that wouldn't get done...Pron heavy

SweetHeatBBQnSC

is One Chatty Farker
Joined
Mar 21, 2019
Location
Johnsonv...
Name or Nickame
Joedy
This weekend I cooked a couple bone in butts for a Church dinner we were having. Caught them for a sweet price of .99 per #. I seasoned them up with some S & P and then hit them with some Sweet Rub O' Mine rub (this rub is ok, but it doesn't knock my socks off by any means). They went on the WSM at 9 p.m. I knew it was going to be a late night, but I had no idea what I was in for.
They were cooking at about 290* so I figured wrapping around 1 or so and hopefully pull them off at 2 or 230. WAY WRONG! Checked around 12:00 and I wanted a little more bark. Checked at 1:00 and the IT was approximately 130, but my fire had burned out. Instead starting a chimney outside I made the executive decision they are going into the oven. Turned the oven to 350* so they would finish and I could let them rest and hash it in the morning...man was I in for a surprise. The butts didn't get done until 5 a.m. The only thing I can think of was I didn't take their size into consideration. One but was 11# and the other was 12#. The others I have cooked have been around 8# but only taken about 5 1/2 hours. I let them rest until 7 and hashed them up add more rub and my homemade vinegar sauce. The BBQ turned out excellent. My miniature loves my bbq which is a blessing and she kills it every time it is made. Thanks for looking.
 

Attachments

  • 20191012_192553.jpg
    20191012_192553.jpg
    47 KB · Views: 446
  • 20191012_203439.jpg
    20191012_203439.jpg
    77.6 KB · Views: 444
  • 20191012_224410.jpg
    20191012_224410.jpg
    66.9 KB · Views: 443
  • 20191013_073610.jpg
    20191013_073610.jpg
    73.2 KB · Views: 445
  • 20191013_073620.jpg
    20191013_073620.jpg
    39.7 KB · Views: 444
  • 20191013_093100.jpg
    20191013_093100.jpg
    73.9 KB · Views: 446
  • 20191013_184147.jpg
    20191013_184147.jpg
    35 KB · Views: 442
Looks like you made it through a tricky cook great! I had one the other day that took about 11 hours running around 300-325 the whole time. Some butts are just going to do whatever they want and we have to be at their mercy ha
 
As long as the main dish was done on time and was enjoyed by all, it doesn't matter how you arrived at that point. I have finished many cooks in the oven for fear of getting them done on time. Very nice results!
 
That last picture is the Seal of Approval!
That little Sweetheart diggin in!
Worth all the worry for that one picture. :pray:
Ya Done GOOD! :thumb:
 
4 hours from 130 IT to done sounds about right to me. I'm assuming there was some time for the oven to get to temp and that you still wrapped them. The surprising thing is that they took 4 hrs to get to 130. That's about 2 hrs too long. But you did mention your fire died...
 
4 hours from 130 IT to done sounds about right to me. I'm assuming there was some time for the oven to get to temp and that you still wrapped them. The surprising thing is that they took 4 hrs to get to 130. That's about 2 hrs too long. But you did mention your fire died...

yeah it surprised me too. I went expecting to wrap and the bark wasn't anywhere near what I had hoped for too. I just went with the saying, all is well that ends well.
 
I sometimes wonder what's going on with pork butts. A 8 to 10 pound butt used to take at most 10 hours to get to pulled pork tenderness, then last year I had one that went 13 hours and was not ready. We had sliced pork that night. Since that one I've had at least 2 more that stayed stuck at stall for longer than usual. I even thought my thermometer was malfunctioning and boiled water to check it. I now allow extra time and make sure I'm ready to wrap in foil and store in a towel lined cooler if the meat is done early.
 
I don't wrap butts because I want good bark. That's 23 lbs of meat you were cooking. Going to take longer. Ended up looking good though and Future Pit Master approved.
 
I always plan for about 45 minutes to an hour per pound on butts. That's not to say total weight of all of them, but pick the largest of them times 45 minutes for the least and an hour for longest. So 12x45=540 (9 hours) to 12x60=720 (12 hours)

This is just a good rule of thumb for me. I try to keep the fire between 250-275 for the duration.
 
Back
Top