Smoke roasted whole New York - Pron included

smokinbadger

Full Fledged Farker
Joined
Sep 17, 2006
Messages
474
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Dexter, MI
Thanks to all of you who gave me advice on how to prepare this hunk of meat. Here's what I bought:




I hit it with a dry rub I put together from kosher salt, black pepper, onion and garlic powder and paprika:



I let the meat sit overnight in the fridge.

This afternoon, I built a fire using cherry wood in the Klose. I gave the meat a quick sear over the firebox:





Then I moved it over to the smoker at 325F.



After about 1:15, it was up to 120F internal temp, so I pulled it off and let it rest for 20 minutes in foil. Here's what it looked like just before slicing:



I think it turned out pretty well:



I had lots left over, so I sliced most of it up for roast beef sandwiches:



Overall, I was very pleased with how this turned out. I like prime rib, but a lot of the time, other than the rim of really tasty meat, I find the core of the roast to be kind of boring and chewy. This was really tender and moist all the way through. For $3.99 a pound, I think I'll pick this over prime rib most every time.
 
What a beautiful hunk of meat. Nice job.
Good find at that price too.
I like to do a whole NY strip roast instead of a Prime rib too.
$4.00 a pound is outstanding. I have not found anywhere close to that recently.
 
Very nice piece of cooking. I really like NY strip.
 
cant beat that price! sometimes krogers will have 'em that cheap but it's always "select" grade. dang that looks good!
 
Very nice, have never seen a NY roast before. At that price you can cook those all day. Around here brisket falt are alot more than that.
 
Very nice.
Great shots and nice technique.
Salivate mod.
 
Overall, I was very pleased with how this turned out. I like prime rib, but a lot of the time, other than the rim of really tasty meat, I find the core of the roast to be kind of boring and chewy. This was really tender and moist all the way through. For $3.99 a pound, I think I'll pick this over prime rib most every time.

I agree with you on prime rib. You could've taken those cut steaks and returned them to the fire box to get some sear on them.
 
What a beautiful hunk of meat. Nice job.
Good find at that price too.
I like to do a whole NY strip roast instead of a Prime rib too.
$4.00 a pound is outstanding. I have not found anywhere close to that recently.
Looks great!!!! I WISH I could find it for that price....
 
Back
Top