I have no experience with either...
There are so many more choices to look at. I spent a year doing research and finally went with an insulated vertical because an 8 pound bag of charcoal will give me a 14 + hour burn with plenty of room for large cooks.
Make a list of you needs, then your wants, and keep the two issues separate, somewhere in between will be your compromise.
You will choose what fits your needs best.
|