Tempature question

Look on the internuts for Italian Beef and Baltimore Pit Beef recipes. Those are both good ways to use that cut.
 
If anyone has a Sous vide, or immersion cooker, make a roast beef in that!!!! Changed my world!!
I sous vide to 125 (18 hrs), then sear.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: EdF
If anyone has a Sous vide, or immersion cooker, make a roast beef in that!!!! Changed my world!!
I sous vide to 125 (18 hrs), then sear.

This is a great way to cook, but I would caution against an extended cook below 130 for food safety, especially with a vacuum bag anaerobic environment. I am not positive 125 is dangerous, but all the published data I have seen suggests 130 is the minimum.
 
I've only ever done 1 eye round. It is very, very lean. My results weren't stellar but they weren't bad either. My advice would be to cook at low temps for as long as you can. I shoot for 125° on most cuts of beef - except brisket, of course - because I like rare cuts and because I can always cut it more, but not less. Remember that if you tent it and let it rest it will continue to cook a bit.


Let us know how it turns out.
 
This is a great way to cook, but I would caution against an extended cook below 130 for food safety, especially with a vacuum bag anaerobic environment. I am not positive 125 is dangerous, but all the published data I have seen suggests 130 is the minimum.

You're right. My bad. I went and checked my recipe....recipe says cook at 131.
So, it was 131 for 18 hrs. Still best way to cook those lean roasts!
 
This is a great way to cook, but I would caution against an extended cook below 130 for food safety, especially with a vacuum bag anaerobic environment. I am not positive 125 is dangerous, but all the published data I have seen suggests 130 is the minimum.

Do you have something on this?

I thought it was a combination of time and temp.

I often cook roasts at 127* for 48 hrs
 
Do you have something on this?

I thought it was a combination of time and temp.

I often cook roasts at 127* for 48 hrs

I don’t have anything handy that is definitive but in addition to Baldwin, I have read studies from the CDC and the UK equivalent of the FDA and a couple university studies and I think they all had pasteurization starting at 130 or maybe 129 with times in hours/tens of minutes. That doesn’t mean 127 for over 24 hours won’t also work (to kill the bugs), but I haven’t seen a source that says it will either. Just putting the caution out there because once you introduce the vacuum bag and an anaerobic environment, the risk for botulism goes way up.
 
I don’t have anything handy that is definitive but in addition to Baldwin, I have read studies from the CDC and the UK equivalent of the FDA and a couple university studies and I think they all had pasteurization starting at 130 or maybe 129 with times in hours/tens of minutes. That doesn’t mean 127 for over 24 hours won’t also work (to kill the bugs), but I haven’t seen a source that says it will either. Just putting the caution out there because once you introduce the vacuum bag and an anaerobic environment, the risk for botulism goes way up.

thanks - i'll bump my chuck roast up to 130 next time.
 
Back
Top