Thanks. I cut the brisket into cubes maybe 1/2-3/4" chilled it in the freezer. The plate, IIRC, was 1/8" or 3/16" which I thought at the time was too fine but it was all I had. I have since bought a 1/4" plate. Single grind.Before grinding brisket I trim the good hard fat, then slice into pieces about as wide as my thumb. When prepping the meat for grinding I remove any of the softer fat and toss it. I par-freeze the meat strips and fat strips so I can alternate them when grinding. I do make some 100% ground brisket, but I use it mainly for chili or taco meat, and make it somewhat coarse. It will have a different texture than say sirloin or chuck. This is an example of my coarse grind for chili or tacos (this is pork, not beef)
As to your patties that were soft, floppy and hard to form: Your meat should be firm out of the grinder, and pretty easy to form. Did you use icy meat? And was this a single or double grind, and what size plate? Did you keep the meat cold after grinding?
The fat I did trim was the easy hard fat. So all the soft fat went into the grind.
Re when you are alternating fat and meat chunks, since there is quite a bit of intramuscular fat, do you think you actually end up with more than 50% fat in the result?
Colors on computer monitors are always difficult but here are the pale brats and the pale hamburger together with red-handled screwdriver:
Really, I think now that the problem was that trimming the brisket fat is such an obvious thing that nobody in the thread bothered to mentioned it. I did trim some because it looked like so much but I also assumed that no mention of trimming meant that no one was trimming. Wrong.