Real Q or NOT ??

[rgrizzle]

Is this real Q or faux Q? Let the debate begin.....

[Kloogee]

It looks yummy regardless of what you call it. Good luck! :decision:

[KotaChuk678]

Not real Q

[Ron_L]

Ummm... It's grilled.

[flyingbassman5]

Have the smoke alarms gone off yet?? If so, then yes, I'd vote real Q! :thumb:

[Ye Olde Party Palace]

Looks oven baked. IMO.

[T-Man]

My friend is this some kind of joke ?

[yakdung]

Grilling is NOT BBQ. But do not tell that to the PBS grilling guy.

[Gasket]

I have the exact same stove top grill pan!

[silverfinger]

Not sure what it is but I would eat it!!

[Bludawg]

That is grilling BBQ takes place in the compartment below wood chips go in a pan under the bottom rack & you might want to disconnect the smoke alarm too:becky:

[rgrizzle]

They were really good. put some a couple of these I put my own bbq sauce on and the others I put Sticky Fingers Carolina Sweet on them. Just so everyone knows the smoke alarms did not go off.

[frognot]

Grilled. Tasty but not que.

[funugy]

Not Q. I've always equated Q with something primal. Ya know, fire, coals, smoke. Just because it has grill marks,it doesn't make it BBQ marks. IMO

[DubfromGA]

Not primal........but I'd hit it.

[Lake Dogs]

Looks delicious, but not BBQ. BBQ is the result of the action of bbqing, that being usually under 300+- degrees using wood smoke in an oven-like chamber (usually called a smoker; sometimes called a pit). I had a wonderful extremely thick (almost 3 fingers deep) ribeye, medium rare this weekend. Wasn't BBQ.

[BBQ Bandit]

Looks delicious, but not BBQ. BBQ is the result of the action of bbqing, that being usually under 300+- degrees using wood smoke in an oven-like chamber (usually called a smoker; sometimes called a pit). I had a wonderful extremely thick (almost 3 fingers deep) ribeye, medium rare this weekend. Wasn't BBQ.


If the griddle was under 300* - on that premise; that might be close to a be a debatable point.
Did you preheat the house to 250, too?

If the griddle was heated to the point of searing meat - that's another direction. Tasty looking, too! :thumb:

[BobM]

It's grilled, but it does look tasty!

[Puckstopper]

Definitley grilled not bbq!

[buccaneer]

It doesn't matter what the consensus is, you either enjoyed it or you didn't.
The rest is gossip and noise.
:yo:

[Freddy j]

Hmm... I'd better eat some while I ponder the question. Wait, what was the question again?

[SmokinJohn]

It looks good from here.

But setting off a smoke alarm while cooking no more makes it Q than putting out a grease fire makes you a fireman.

[NorthwestBBQ]

Blasphemy.

[rgrizzle]

Well the wife would say yes it's bbq because it has "bbq sauce on it" to me it's faux q

[wolt98]

Sorry....not Q

[Bonewagon]

I agree - not 'que. I don't see a crockpot... :behindsofa: :bolt: :becky:

[Johnny_Crunch]

Grilled but not Q

[gtr]

Gimme some of that with taters and I'll call it whatever you wanna call it. :hungry:

[cholloway]

Looks fantastic but, you can't BBQ inside.

[gtr]

This guy can BBQ inside.

http://www.followmefoodie.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/Smittys-Market-July-25-12.jpg

[cholloway]

Touche but, I DID say you, not him!:-P

[Limp Brisket]

Uh, no.

[Beerbecue]

Two things make barbecue taste the way it does. They are: flame and /or smoke. If there is no flame or smoke contacting the food then it's not BBQ.

[kds9547]

NOT... but looks good anyway.

[leanza]

Cmon. It's not in the ball park. We all know how BBQ is defined, at even at it's base. It still looks good though. I would want some.

[westy]

Thos is porky chops. I seen em in piturs. Looks yummy. And thats a grill pan! Barbecues are out back. Im hungry again.