Experience with The Steak Ager

HuffDaddy BBQ

Found some matches.
Joined
Feb 15, 2017
Location
Bixby, OK
A couple of years ago when I was in Chicago for work, I got to eat at Primehouse, the David Burke restaurant that is famous for dry aging steaks. I was blown away by the flavor and the texture. I was not blown away by the price.
In December of last year, I was listening to the BBQ Central Show podcast (after all, I am the Official Embeded Oklahoma Correspondent") and he had a guest who was promoting his invention "The Steak Ager". $200 dollars later I had it in my fridge.
I read some of the posts on here about it but thought I would share my experience. Started last January with a prime boneless rib eye from Costco. Aged it for 45 days. Since it was over winter, the fridge in my garage stayed plenty cold but the dry air had me struggling to keep the humidity above 30%. Trimmed into steaks, seared in cast iron and gave it a shot. Results were just so-so. Steak definitely had the nutty aromas and flavor but the texture was not nearly as tender.
My second attempt was a bone-in prime rib eye, aged for 29 days. This was in April-May so the humidity stayed above 70% but I fridge temp had me a little worried as it crept up to 42-43 during the middle of the day. But I was assured it would be safe so I treated it the same way as last time. Trimmed it, cut into steaks but this time I grilled them using Grill Grates on my Yoder. The results were much improved. Not quite the same strength in flavor (nuttiness was more suttle) but the texture was much improved. Pictures are below.

So my question to those that have played around with aging... What do you think made for better results. Assuming the meat was about the same quality on both roasts...was it
  • Higher humidity?
  • Bone in (protecting one side)?
  • Aging time?
  • Cooking method?
I have my opinions but wanted to get the thoughts from some of you seasoned vets first.

17760242_10154295923747413_2555111748514077242_n.jpg


17904346_10154295924612413_2191205008157135868_n.jpg


18403604_10154370900457413_8959674600331358958_n.jpg


18423758_10154370900467413_6603813429171818884_n.jpg


18403675_10154370900472413_705334549771840589_n.jpg


18424246_10154370900482413_7136964889546736682_n.jpg


18485523_10154370900552413_872261478352608813_n.jpg


18425328_10154370900557413_5457818498602993265_n.jpg


18519541_10154370904862413_3987315141034410809_n.jpg
 
Great post, I am sure others will chime in. A lot of folks on here are into aging.
 
Aging time most likely. I have never been brave enough to let my UMAI dry-bag aged steaks go for 45 days though. Longest I have done is a month. I've been happy with the results, but the trim loss as evidenced in your pictures makes me cry.
 
I just did a bone-in rib roast with the Umai bags for 35 days. (First time). I've very happy with the results - the meat (choice) was tender and very rich. But it didn't have the tastes I was expecting. Next time I think I'll try 45 days.

I can't really say with the small amount of experience which factor affected your outcomes most, but I'd suspect the humidity, based on drying bresaola by hanging it from the roof in our porch entry. More humidity was better.
 
I have done 4 or 5 umai dry bag runs. I would say get a fridge that's consistently stays cold and get better marbled steaks. Thats some weak marbling for prime. The fat is what gives you the flavors your looking for. Nice run!
 
I want to try this as well. Was going to order the umai bags and try them. Bet the wife won't like that black looking meat in the garage fridge though!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
Yeah, I'm scared sh*tless to try this:shock:. I'm just now talking myself into trying curing for bacon.

It's a bit scary to get into aging, fermenting and so on. But if you follow all the great advice out there, there's really not much risk. And the benefits - well!
 
I want to try this as well. Was going to order the umai bags and try them. Bet the wife won't like that black looking meat in the garage fridge though!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

She'll forgive you when she tastes it. Just went through that. Helps if she helped find the meat on sale - more skin in the game.
 
45 days,naked, is the sweet spot for me.I really prefer a 21 day wet age followed by a 45 day dry age.I have gone longer but prefer 45.
 
45 days,naked, is the sweet spot for me.I really prefer a 21 day wet age followed by a 45 day dry age.I have gone longer but prefer 45.

Yeah, from what I'm gathering that's going to be the number! Thanks!
 
Back
Top