watg?
is Blowin Smoke!
Before I begin this long ramble I would like to make a statement. I am in no way criticizing the contest reps, organizers, committee members and or winners of this contest. Those that know me know I do not have a habit of complaining about contests results or judges and this post is in no way meant to be critical of the contest outcome or the folks that worked to put it on.
That being said, I am just back from the Keystone BBQ Classic in Harrisburg PA held at the Pennsylvania Farm Complex in conjunction with a huge livestock show. Due to the unusually heavy rainfall last Wendsday & Thursday here in the northeast, the location of the contest was moved from a grass site to an asphalt parking lot, all within the same complex. As saturated as the ground was, I am sure this was a good decision.
In moving the site for the teams, the judging area was also moved. Originally planned to be located in a large lobby of one of the complex buildings the judge’s area was moved to a large indoor active animal stall area. The building was huge, concrete floors, expansive ceilings, with several hundred large animal stalls, many containing horses.
As I am sure you could imagine the aromas associated with numerous horses being keep within the confines of any type of building are noticeable to say the least. The staff and horse-people where very diligent in the cleaning of the area but the fact remains, the area had a bit of a smell. Several times during the contest as I strolled to the very well maintained human rest rooms that were also located within this building, I had to walk to and fro in order to avoid stepping into large piles of fresh horse droppings, all of which added to the area potpourri.
My questions here are simple. Do you think that judging competition BBQ within the confines of a horse stable makes sense? Can it be done? Isn’t the sense of smell and taste very much connected and related? I mean, what is next, a contest with a judging area in a waste treatment plant, an active landfill, or maybe a chicken farm?
I know I am having fun here, but the bottom line question is this, can you eat, taste and score competition BBQ with your caboose parked in a closed building containing fresh animal droppings and all of the associated aromas? Or am I imagining things, it doesn't matter where you are dining, when your task is to judge que, your surroundings and area odors do not matter.
Whataya think?
That being said, I am just back from the Keystone BBQ Classic in Harrisburg PA held at the Pennsylvania Farm Complex in conjunction with a huge livestock show. Due to the unusually heavy rainfall last Wendsday & Thursday here in the northeast, the location of the contest was moved from a grass site to an asphalt parking lot, all within the same complex. As saturated as the ground was, I am sure this was a good decision.
In moving the site for the teams, the judging area was also moved. Originally planned to be located in a large lobby of one of the complex buildings the judge’s area was moved to a large indoor active animal stall area. The building was huge, concrete floors, expansive ceilings, with several hundred large animal stalls, many containing horses.
As I am sure you could imagine the aromas associated with numerous horses being keep within the confines of any type of building are noticeable to say the least. The staff and horse-people where very diligent in the cleaning of the area but the fact remains, the area had a bit of a smell. Several times during the contest as I strolled to the very well maintained human rest rooms that were also located within this building, I had to walk to and fro in order to avoid stepping into large piles of fresh horse droppings, all of which added to the area potpourri.
My questions here are simple. Do you think that judging competition BBQ within the confines of a horse stable makes sense? Can it be done? Isn’t the sense of smell and taste very much connected and related? I mean, what is next, a contest with a judging area in a waste treatment plant, an active landfill, or maybe a chicken farm?
I know I am having fun here, but the bottom line question is this, can you eat, taste and score competition BBQ with your caboose parked in a closed building containing fresh animal droppings and all of the associated aromas? Or am I imagining things, it doesn't matter where you are dining, when your task is to judge que, your surroundings and area odors do not matter.
Whataya think?