Recipe: Panini-Style Muffaletta (lots o' pics)

PatioDaddio

Babbling Farker
Joined
May 4, 2008
Messages
3,034
Reaction score
2...
Points
0
Location
Boise...
Panini-Style Muffaletta

This sandwich is my funky twist on a muffaletta. It's one of those recipes
that I made up on-the-fly while doing the, "What in the world am I gonna
make for dinner?" mental gymnastics on my way home from work last night.
I wanted something quick and easy, yet new and interesting.

ItalianMuffaletta_1_10_630.jpg


As I was parking at the store I remembered this great sandwich recipe from
chef Anne Burrell. I didn't remember the entire recipe, but I did recall
enough to be inspired by it. This happens to me alot. Here's how the rest
of this little culinary adventure went down.

I grabbed a loaf of take & bake ciabatta and that's when I came up with
the "panini-style" idea. The bread needs to be baked anyhow, so why not
try something new? A panini would be great, and while I don't have a
panini press, I do have a baking stone and a large cast iron griddle with a
grill on the other side. Bingo! It was a true Alton Brown-esque moment.

Next I went looking for something to approximate the pepper relish that
Anne used. As I scoured the shelves I saw a small jar of roasted red
pepper tapanade. It looked promising (albeit expensive), so I threw it in
the basket.

Cheese was on the list of needs, and while in that section I realized that I
had plenty of various cheeses at home. Just as I moved along I discovered
something even more interesting to replace the relish — roasted red pepper
pesto. "Ah yes, that's even better.", I thought.

I hit the pickle aisle because I needed something to add a vinegar twang. I
grabbed a jar of mild pickled banana pepper rings. My girls dig just about
anything pickled, and I thought these would add not only the needed
twang, but also a great texture and another dimension of flavor.

Now I needed the meat. I am a huge fan of Boar's Head deli products.
Their stuff is a little pricey, but the quality is definitely worth it. While the
deli dude was slicing my tavern ham (like Black Forest, but a little sweeter
with a lighter smoke), I saw the olives that I was lacking. What is a
muffaletta without olives? The olive loaf was calling me. Yes, olive loaf.
This is at least the third time that I've ever in my life bought olive loaf.

With all the ingredients in hand, it's time to make a stellar sandwich!

Ingredients
1 loaf (12 oz) Take & bake ciabatta bread
1/4 lb Deli ham, sliced very thin
1/4 lb Deli olive loaf, sliced very thin (or substitute mortadella)
6-8 slices Havarti, Swiss or provolone cheese
1/3 cup Roasted red pepper pesto
Pickled pepper rings to taste

ItalianMuffaletta_1_1.jpg


Method
Put your baking stone on the center rack of your oven, and your cast iron
griddle on a lower rack.

Note: If you don't have a cast iron griddle, a large cast iron skillet will work
nicely.

Preheat the oven to 400º.

Split the loaf of bread in half horizontally and press down on the internal
bread of each half to compress it.

ItalianMuffaletta_1_2.jpg


Spread half of the pesto evenly on each half of the bread.

ItalianMuffaletta_1_3.jpg


Cover each half of the bread completely and evenly with the cheese.

Arrange the ham evenly on one half of the bread, and the olive loaf on the
other.

Distribute the pepper rings evenly on one half.

ItalianMuffaletta_1_4.jpg


Carefully close the sandwich.

ItalianMuffaletta_1_5.jpg


Put the sandwich in the center of the baking stone.

Very carefully center the griddle on top of the sandwich.

Note: It's important that it be centered so that it doesn't slide off in one
direction as the sandwich cooks. This happened to me.

ItalianMuffaletta_1_6.jpg


Bake the sandwich for 15 minutes, or until the edges of the bread are
golden brown and starting to crisp.

ItalianMuffaletta_1_7.jpg


Remove the sandwich to a cutting board.

Slice and enjoy!

-----

John
 
Last edited:
Great idea! I love paninis but have never thought about cooking them outside on a grill.

FYI - the Roasted Red Pepper Tapenade would have been a good combo of olives/peppers. It is expensive, but then you could trade the olive loaf for something else (I like mortadella as you mentioned).

i usually get a premium jarred olive or bulk olives off the salad bar and hit them in the food processor to make my own tapenade and that will either save you money or give you a higher quality product depending on what you buy. Roasted red peppers, red pepper flakes, and cloves of olives are my favorite things to add to a tapenade.
 
While the sandwich looks good, it's really not a muffaletta. A muffaletta has a marinated olive salad, then layers of capicola, salami, mortadella, emmentaler, and provolone.

Maybe you can call it a muffaletta-ish or a muffaletta-like? :becky:

I'd still hit it, however. :-D
 
Great idea! I love paninis but have never thought about cooking them outside on a grill.

I've done paninis on the grill before using a cast iron skillet and a brick for weight. They come out good, but you do have to flip it since the main heat source is on one side.
 
I'll eat Ron's piece. Looks DEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEELICIOUS. :thumb::thumb::thumb:
 
Another PatioDaddyo bookmark. I really like how specific and detail oriented you are in your instructions. Write a book, man! :clap2:
 
The instructions were not very clear; please make a dozen of the sandwiches and
send them to me. I will then reverse engineer them and figure out the process at
that time. Also, this is not a lame attempt to get a dozen fantastic sandwiches for
free. It is a legitimate scam. Please send them to my attorney at the Law
Office of: Giam Hungry, Ivana Eadnow, and Donna Napkin.
 
Thanks to all of you for your continued kind comments and encouragement.

John
 
Back
Top