Sorry, I'm going to rant now...long!
I have had a major issue with the way KCBS tells judges to score chicken for quite some time now. The whole "if the juices run red, it's undercooked" statement simply isn't true.
Case in point. In late 2010 at QueenCreek, AZ we tried out a modification of our chicken recipe. It involved injecting thighs with a liquid that was reddish. We injected our heavily-trimmed thighs liberally along each side of the bone in the middle of the meat. Added rub and cooked at 300 over coals. Temps were 180-185 internally on both sides of each thigh as they hit the turn in box (overcooked IMHO).
Here are our chicken scores from that event.
J1 8 8 7
J2 8 6 7
J3 7 8 7
J4 8 2 2
J5 9 9 9
J6 8 8 8
Comment card from J4 read "Juices ran red, afraid to taste". TC and the Rep both got involved and apparently really tried to get a T/T score from J4. Still, it was a no go and J4 never actually sampled the product.
Herein lies the issue, IMO. J4 reportedly never tasted the chicken. KCBS Judge Rule #3 states that "The judge will then score each entry for taste and tenderness, before moving to the next entry". That never happened.
I know that we learned in the two judging classes that we took to spit out unedible food discreetly in a napkin, as to not modify the other table judges scores. I wonder how J4's actions and involvement of the TC and Rep may have possibly affected the other judges scores on our turn-in.
In all fairness to KCBS, it was determined through the napkin test, that the juices did have a slight red tint to them on J4's sample. I do 100% respect the decision of the Reps and really only question J4. What I don't respect is the fact that I sent emails to members of the KCBS board to address the issue and.....hold on to your hat's folks.....I got absolutely no replies to my questions.
Not that it matters, but we finished 16th out of 37 in the Chicken category at the Queen Creek event after J4's score got dropped.
Two weeks later in the Tucson KCBS event, cooking 100% exactly the same way, we got lucky and finished 3rd out of 34 in the chicken category.
My opinion and my point is that there are rogue judges out there.....and be careful when you inject chicken with reddish stuff. :-D