Electric Smoker questions again

S

suprfast

Guest
Long story short, moved to an apt and can only use electric for smoking. Had two UDS, I know they are the best and realize I am downgrading.

Now that is out of the way with. I had a thread a month back or so but I wanted some fresh answers to some different smokers

Found this one. Anyone heard about it?
http://www.amazon.com/Smokin-It-Model-1-Electric-Smoker/dp/B002VGE36S/ref=cm_cr_pr_product_top

Then the masterbuilt
http://www.amazon.com/Masterbuilt-2...1?ie=UTF8&s=home-garden&qid=1279096689&sr=8-1

And lastly this one, but i doubt I would splurge on the money for something that still only hits 250°F
http://www.amazon.com/Smokin-Tex-Stainless-Electric-Smoker/dp/B000NCX5NY/ref=pd_sbs_ol_2

I saw a few guys talking highly of the last, never of the first and mixed reviews on the middle. I am leaning more towards the middle because it has the space I need for my day to day while hitting the higher temps(275° vs 250° for the other two). Would this still be the best choice or would the stainless looking model be a better investment? Are their electric smokers that produce higher temps than 275° for the hot and fast smokers out there?
 
I have the smokin tex in my team of smokers. Its absolutely fantastic for pork butts..uses little wood and its set and forget...however, for ribs, I didnt like it to much.

The top one is the same as the smokin tex, just a cheaper brand. Im not sure of the Masterbuilt.

For the price ranges you are looking in, I would consider a small pellet pooper like small traeger, or louisianna grill pellet smoker.

david
 
I own the Masterbuilt. It's a great little smoker and produces some great meat. I also had a customer service when it was out of warranty and it was no questions asked, they took care of it. I don't feel you can go wrong with the Masterbuilt Digital Smokehouse.
 
I have a Hi Mountain Jerky & Prime Rib Oven which is really a Cookshack Smokette 008. It looks like the first and last ones in the link. I think it does pretty good pork butts, jerky and a kick ass rib roast, but have not been impressed with my ribs cooked on it.
Personally I think its too small, but for an apartment dweller that needs a good little smoker that doesn't put out a bunch of smoke to rile the neighbors or property manager, any of them would probably be fine.
 
I also have the Masterbuilt and love it. I can load it up in the morning, set the temp, go to work, and when I get home have some nice supper. I've done ribs, butts, chickens, and hams on it

Its a little small do be doing more than a family cook on it. It is what it is in that respect.
 
go to www.cabelas.com and type in "masterbuilt". They often have various models on sale. I like the stainless myself.
 
I have a Cookshack Smokette that works great but is limited on capacity. Guy at work has a Masterbuilt and loves it. Guy has a Bradley and not happy with it.

No Propane?
 
If I was getting one it would be the 40" Masterbuilt with the window. The window is too cool in my opinion.
 
I have the
Smokin-It Model #2


works great and love the set and forget it, I did a 9 lb butt Saturday night and Sunday morning it was at 199. put it in a cooler for 2 hrs and had lunch at 12 :thumb:
 
The Smokin Tex is a knockoff of Cookshack and it's made in China.

The current version of the Cookshacks will hit 300 (better element).

The only variance between what you're looking at it quality, cheaper means thinner metal and probably won't hold heat as well or the heating element won't hold stable temps.

Really depends on how much you want to use it, but the CS will last a long time. I run the CS forum, but don't work for them. If you have any specific questions, I'll try to help, not try to steer you one way or the other, just want you to be fully informed. FYI, the CS has a 100% money back guarantee.

Russ
 
I go to bed and wake up to all these wonderful replies. I have a three year program at school so I just need something to get me through the few years. I must admit that it's been almost a month since I have smoked something, and I need a fix bad.

I am leaning towards a purchase on amazon because I have a couple hundred dollars in amazon gift cards. My goal is just to find the right one for my needs, which isn't that high. I smoke mainly for myself and my daughter(gotta love the 9yr old that loves good food).

The Masterbuilt might be the smoker I go with but I'll give it a few more days worth of searching before I finalize.

Thanks again for everything guys.
kris
 
I have the Masterbuilt and really like it for set and forget smoking. I don't use it as often as I did when we lived in a condo, but you can get 6 big buttss into and cook them low and slow all night.
 

Attachments

  • Butts 001.jpg
    Butts 001.jpg
    71.8 KB · Views: 88
AQUA, that is EXACTLY what i wanted to see. Looks like my beef short ribs will fit perfect in there.
 
I wanted to say thanks to everyone and I finally decided to get the Masterbuilt. Great part was my wife had it ready for me at home after she picked me up for class. Small trade off since she just bought a kindle to go along with her nook.

Now to business. Do I water pan or not? Anything I should know?
kris
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

J
Electric smoker dying
Replies
16
Views
623
JIMSMOKES
J
16Adams
Electric Knife Sharpener - Hero or Zero
Replies
13
Views
1K
Fooball
F
W
Two Butts in the "electric chair"
Replies
9
Views
5K
Cat797
C
snadamo
Outdoor Deep Fryer Suggestions
2
Replies
27
Views
2K
Callahan-que
Callahan-que
cayenne
OK...The chainsaw for proper length splits solved the problem!!
Replies
9
Views
718
Kevin James
K
Back
Top