How do you cook your tri-tip?

SteelSmokin

Full Fledged Farker
Joined
Oct 21, 2009
Messages
334
Reaction score
95
Points
0
Location
Sharpsville,PA
I'll be doing a tri-tip tomorrow and was just wondering how everybody does theirs just trying to get some different ideas.
 
I prep mine like I would ribs. Worcestershire sauce rubbed over the meat, then coated with your favorite rub and cook at 225 until internal temp is between 130-140 depending on how done you like it.
 
Basic Santa Maria style would be salt, pepper, lots of granulated garlic as a rub, then cooked to internal of around 125F (medium rare) in a smoker at around 275F using red oak for the smoke, then post sear on a hot grill.

I use a basic BBQ rub instead of just salt, add pepper, and lots of granulated garlic (the granulated garlic composes half of the rub, really!) and use hickory instead.

I *LOVE* this stuff on sammies day 2.

Don
 
The two I did on Tuesday had Montreal Steak seasoning on the outside, and I tried an injection for the first time. We even did a reverse sear. Turned out really good, wife said it was a bit too peppery for her though.

Matt
 
Rub with salt, pepper & garlic then sear @ 500+* then turn down the temp to medium high and cook until internal temp of 135*

1005230g.jpg


1005234.jpg
 
Basic Santa Maria style would be salt, pepper, lots of granulated garlic as a rub, then cooked to internal of around 125F (medium rare) in a smoker at around 275F using red oak for the smoke, then post sear on a hot grill.

I use a basic BBQ rub instead of just salt, add pepper, and lots of granulated garlic (the granulated garlic composes half of the rub, really!) and use hickory instead.

I *LOVE* this stuff on sammies day 2.

Don

Big fan of the "reverse sear" myself. Agree with cooking to around 125ish...with the shape of this piece of meat you often get a higher temp at the point than on the thicker side.

Once I'm at around 125 I'll cooler it while I jack the fire up as hot as I can get if before searing for a couple minutes a side.

My tri rub has salt, pepper, paprika, oregano, thyme, rosemary and I marinate in garlic/olive oil before hand.

Tri-tip is some good eatin'
 
Muster slather, Montreal steak, cook @ 300-350 pit till 130 (I go 135-140 as wife/daughter get squimish) reverse sear, rest, enjoy
 
Marinade for a few hours in a simple marinade of EVOO, Worster, and Soy sauce then Rub with Montreal Steak seasoning.

I usually do a reverse sear, smoking to about 130* then crisp it up on the gasser.
 
Salt & Pepper all over
Indirect heat on kettle charcoal and wood
Baste every 6 minutes with 50/50 mixture of melted butter and A1 Bold
At 130 internal sear both sides
Pull, rest, carve & eat.

OR

Santa Maria Rub from Rub Co. And smoke until 130 internal and sear.
 
Thanks for all the ideas never did a reverse sear think ill try tgatt with the salt,pepper,garlic rub would u say 50 or 75% garlic?
 
I don't have a smoker...yet... So I like to grill mine on a charcoal grill. I like to season it with black pepper and some garlic powder with a dash of kosher salt. Then I toss it over high heat and, depending on the thickness, cook it for about 3 minutes on each side. Then I move it over to indirect heat and let it cook until medium rare. I don't really cook according to temp, although I probably should, I just go by how it feels when I poke it.
 
I don't have a smoker...yet... So I like to grill mine on a charcoal grill. I like to season it with black pepper and some garlic powder with a dash of kosher salt. Then I toss it over high heat and, depending on the thickness, cook it for about 3 minutes on each side. Then I move it over to indirect heat and let it cook until medium rare. I don't really cook according to temp, although I probably should, I just go by how it feels when I poke it.

This is the way to go. :thumb:

For me same as above except lots of black pepper and seasoning salt. No need to kill it with a bunch of extra crap.
 
I just bought my Phirst tri tip and gonna smoke it tomorrow.
Don't know what rub I'm gonna use,Raising the Steaks is calling me.....and if I ain't gonna use that one I'm gonna make a homemade rub with the info that's in this thread.
Probably I'll ask Brother Niek for a recipe cause he's a tri tip Master!:cool:
 
Rub with salt, pepper & garlic then sear @ 500+* then turn down the temp to medium high and cook until internal temp of 135*

1005230g.jpg


1005234.jpg

You got that beautiful medium rare finish by pulling at 135???? I usually pull around 120 after high heat grilling and carryover takes it up to about 125-130. Pulling at 135 (which ive done on accident) has resulted in carryover cooking till around 140 which is medium and way over cooked for me.
 
You got that beautiful medium rare finish by pulling at 135???? I usually pull around 120 after high heat grilling and carryover takes it up to about 125-130. Pulling at 135 (which ive done on accident) has resulted in carryover cooking till around 140 which is medium and way over cooked for me.

Yep, 135* is my target when I do tri tip. My thermo actually lists rare beef at 140* and med rare at 145*:crazy: As you can see by all the juice on the plate I probably didn't let it rest long enough for the temp to carry over to much.
 
Big fan of the "reverse sear" myself. Agree with cooking to around 125ish...with the shape of this piece of meat you often get a higher temp at the point than on the thicker side.

Once I'm at around 125 I'll cooler it while I jack the fire up as hot as I can get if before searing for a couple minutes a side.

My tri rub has salt, pepper, paprika, oregano, thyme, rosemary and I marinate in garlic/olive oil before hand.

Tri-tip is some good eatin'

Perfecto!!
 
You got that beautiful medium rare finish by pulling at 135???? I usually pull around 120 after high heat grilling and carryover takes it up to about 125-130. Pulling at 135 (which ive done on accident) has resulted in carryover cooking till around 140 which is medium and way over cooked for me.

I agree that if you have a target of 135 then you need to pull at about 120.
 
Back
Top