I've settled on the Country Smoker - but which one?

Hi everyone! New member! I currently have a Pitts 'N Spitts U1830. I bought it back in 1999 and it's still in great shape. (It's also on Craig's List.) It's a great hardwood offset smoker but I've decided to become a Pellet Pooper! These forums have helped me a lot in digging through my initial evaluation of GBE, Traeger and Country Cooker. I'm not really wanting to stir up that debate and I realize they are all good choices for various reasons. As I stated - I've settled on the Country Smoker.

My dilemma is between the Tailgater and something larger - probably the 570. All things being equal (without worrying about the price difference), I figure I'd much rather be able to 4 briskets for a big occasion. Just say'n!

However, my REALLY big hobby is pulling an RV. I've never been satisfied with my portable grills and the Tailgater seems like a dream come true for that purpose.

So here's my questions:

How much can I really put in a Tailgater and get good quality? It claims a 25 lb turkey. It doesn't say so but that would seem to be big enough for a nice size brisket or 3 racks of BB ribs on a rib rack.

Are hot spots a problem in the smallish Tailgater chamber?

If I go with a 570 or 480, how tough will it be to put in the back of my pickup. I've got a Ford F450 with a 5th wheel hitch. Lifting one of these up and between the hitch and the bed doesn't seem like a 1 man job. However, if there is a way to get the legs on and off easy enough, I might be able put it between the hitch and the tailgate. I figure some of you comp guys have experience in moving these things and might have some advise.

Thanks in advance and thanks for all the good posts in the past that have helped me get to this point!

Do you find yourself typically cooking the same type foods RV'ing? I don't think you will get a very big brisket on the tailgator and not sure how often you have to replenish pellets.

Buster Dog BBQ said:

Do you find yourself typically cooking the same type foods RV'ing? I don't think you will get a very big brisket on the tailgator and not sure how often you have to replenish pellets.

Click to expand...

I'm hoping to be able to expand what I'm cooking in my RV. I really like ribs and can only imagine cook'n some slow smoked ribs while kicking back!

However, as a tangent to my original questions - how well does your mini BGE work? I've research the BGE egg a bit and know it is great but I've been suspicious about a mini. As an alternative to getting a Tailgater for the RV, a mini BGE might really scratch an itch. I know we're not talking brisket and ribs but how well does it work for a 1.5 - 2 inch prime steak? I could get the 480 or 570 for the homestead and a mini BGE for the RV if it can do some quality small scale cooking!

If I had my choice for an RV I would take the tailgator. The rectangle shape would allow for ribs, more room for steaks, brats, etc. Plus you have a indirect cooking which has it's benefits. Heck, you can always pick up an ez grill if you want over the coals on occasion.

The mini egg hinge is worthless in my opinion unless you get the new hinge assembly. But it does sear better than most things. I only use it for burgers, hot dogs, steaks and a few other things. I dont have any thing yet to do indirect on it.

Chef Country said:

if you have a hitch on the back of your rv you could get one of these

I built my own but it works great for hauling a grill behind the 5er

Click to expand...

My 5th doesn't have a hitch (that sounds like a song!)

The only thing there is that tail end can really bounce. It's a 40' trailer so there's a long way between the axle and the tail end. Thanks for the idea! That's what makes this place cook!

Thanks for all the feedback. There are a couple of Country Smoker dealers in the Dallas area but they are 50 miles away!.

Traeger is a lot more popular. In fact, they will be coming by my Costco in December and it looks like they'll have the 75 for $795. It's a nice price. I'll go and look at the CS and get a better sense of it.

If money weren't an issue I'd buy a Tailgater and 680! The 420 sounds like an interesting compromise. I'll see if I can find one.

Plowboy said:

I'm not a fan of the new CS since they went to China. They leak air.

Click to expand...

CS is made in China now too? That's been the knock against Traiger. I stopped by a CS dealer this weekend and he said they are still made in Canada. However, I suspect you're more on top of this than he is.

I must say, I didn't see a big difference between Traeger and CS. It's not like either one is made with 3/8" steel.

After stopping by the CS dealer this weekend I'm inclined to get the 680. The Tailgater is nice and will do most of the cooking I plan on doing... just not as much of it. Maybe in a year or so I can get the second one.

My final concern is the searing heat of the CS 680. It looks like all of the CS units have the same combustion design. The bigger the more it takes to heat it. The biggest difference between the Traeger and the CS is the reported top end heat. This question may be be a thread for itself but there are a few 680 owners on this one.

What is the top end searing heat on the CS 680?

Thanks again guys. It looks like I've got buyer for P&S for $550. 600 degrees may not be a match for BGE but it will do some important work for bazeing roasts and getting medium rare steaks. That's the difference between a CS a comperable sized Traeger. Now I just have to finish the sale and get my dealer to special order the the 680. He doesn't stock them. Looks like'll be without a smoker for thanksgiving. Deep fried turkey again.

Happy Turkey Day to you all!

I sold my Pitts N Spitts. I got $550. Not as much as I wanted but not to bad for being 11 years old.

CS 680 shipped last week. I'm going Analog to start with. We don't have as much big swings in temperature in Dallas as a lot of the country.

Cooked Ribs on my Brinkmann yesterday. I guess I needed one last battle so I'll know why I'm getting a pellet smoker. I won't call it a whipping because doing the Q always has some pluses.