Wow this is a tough one. I'm going to need to talk myself through this one to find a winner. Warning: this may come off as harsh in some cases but please keep in mind that this is a very tight race and I am grasping at straws here on a few of these. I promise I will enter a throwdown soon so that everyone may rip me as well.
bigabyte: I prefer even numbers, 8 meatballs may have gotten you my vote.
scottjess: Too many hints, I wanted to find the meatballs on my own.
BBQ4FUN: MOINK violation (venison/beef enough said) good looking money shot though.
SirPorkaLot: Very nice entry. I would hit that all day. In the end though you failed to hold off the General's zombie troops. See Gore's entry.
caseydog: That is a good looking meatball but I just had spaghetti and meatballs last night for dinner an ate way too much. I still feel sick thinking about it. Let's pretend I was offended by the fork crutch.
Redhot: You had me all worked up until I saw the chopped olives. I just don't like olives. I will make this someday, as soon as I find a suitable replacement for the olives.
Boshizzle: See: caseydog. Spaghetti and meatball hangover. Love the cheese though.
Cack: Not nearly enough bacon in the meatballs, try not to eat so much next time. Fine looking sub though.
Pappy: The meatballs I ate too much of last night were turkey meatballs. See: caseydog and Boshizzle.
DaveMW: Dude I'm from the northeast and couldn't let this one slide it's HOAGIE roll. Note: would still hit that.
Lazybones: I would have stuck the potato under the broiler to melt the cheese. Nitpicking here.
oldyote: Creative use of meatball ingredients. Perhaps plated on a toasted slice of rye? still in the running.
silverfinger: Hmm, ground beef, bacon, Oakridge, 2 kinds of cheese. I do love sandwiches. In the running.
N8man: The meatballs looked awesome, maybe too awesome. I fear there was some enhancement added to the final TD shot. Maybe it was the zombies.
Bluetang: That's a fine looking sandwich right there. Just a little too spicy for me.
HighQ: My parents used to make me sit at the table until I ate all of my peas. It scarred me for life.
Colonel00: Ground chuck, pizza dough, tons of cheese, butter and herbs, cooked on Darth Stewie. In the running.
ecode: The meatball got lost in the pie for me, not enough focus on the meatball. That said, I clipped that post to evernote for further review in my own kitchen.
Gore: I'm scared of zombie's and I definitely would not want to eat one, no matter who's grandmother came up with the recipe.
Decisions, decisions.
