• working on DNS.. links may break temporarily.

I may stop using lump

T

Tim Campbell

Knows what a fatty is.
Joined
Aug 12, 2012
Messages
133
Reaction score
27
Points
0
Location
Bristol, CT
I think I am too knew and I need to use something like Kingsford until I learn more. It seems like lump requires more "work" then regular charcoal does. I am always adding lump in my 22" WSM.
 
You are not wrong. Sparky, freaky lump does not Minion well at all in a WSM. Jim Minion uses KB. He fills the ring and uses a weed burner to start the top coals. Then he puts his wood chunks on top. Anything else is not Minion.
 
There are some quality natural briquettes on the market. My Mini WSM (sjs) does not like lump at all. I used a full chimney of Kingsford Blue to cook two Oryx Fatty's last eve, had plenty of run time remaining. Tried lump twice and it was a PITA.
 
But I do like lump in the Akorn. Sometimes I mix lump/briquettes. Just checked and I have five different brands of charcoal. Kingsford,Royal Oak, Cowboy, Stubbs and Ozark Oak.
 
One of the reasons you may have difficulty in your burn may be because lump burns much cleaner and hotter.

I have seen people make a charcoal basket in a maze manner to use lump in the minion manner of controlling their burn.

Here is a picture from another post from "KotaChuk678" who used expanded metal for such a project. This is his picture from another thread, NOT MINE.

KotaChuk678's Basket for Lump Charcoal

DSCN1071_zpsc661fd6f.jpg
 
A maze like that is fine for a stick burner or a Backwoods, etc, but it's not needed for a WSM. As Michael said, I use briquettes in my WSMs. I've used lump with good results, but I get a longer burn with briquettes.

How long did your WSM burn before you had to add fuel, Tim? How much did you put in to start and how much lit did you add? I always fill the ring as full as it will go and then add lit charcoal in a depression in the middle. For my 18.5" WSM I add 10-12 briquettes or the equivalent amount of lump.
 
You might want to try a mix. I use 80/20 KB to lump and minion.

Sent from my SCH-I500 using Tapatalk 2
 
I dont know.

I have a Master Forge vertical which is basically a cheap WSM clone equivalent to a 18" WSM I would guess

I use Wicked Good lump, a full pan lasted me 15 hours at 225f using an Auber ATC. I think the ATC really helps in fuel comsumption

Here are some pics of the first test cook I did. This was a before and after shot of the pan. The pan was not completely full like it was for the 15 hr cook. I did some country ribs then some bacon. I set it to 160f for the bacon. I did add a few more chunks of hickory along the way,

I started it by lighting 20 briqs in a chimney and pouring them on top. I snuffed out the fire after about 8 hours and this is what was left

I am very happy using this lump anyway
 
Last edited:
I almost always use briquettes in my WSMs and Minis. I just find them to be more predictable and manageable than lump. I'll use KB in a pinch, but prefer some of the all natural brands like Lazzari.
 
I mix KBlue & lump in my WSM with great results. I pour a double layer of KBlue briquettes first and press them down. Then, I add wood chunks and lump to cover the KBlue and leave a slight indent in the middle to pour in 15-25 lit KBlue briquettes to get the Minion burn started.

Since I started cooking most everything @ 275°, the lump helps keep my WSM at that temp easier than just using KBlue alone.
 
I use lump in my WSM and I think it works better than briquette. I fill the ring with lump..a few pieces of desired wood added. To start...I stick a small propane torch
thru one of the vents for about 3-5 mins. Leave all the vents wide open till dome temp reaches 150...then start closing vents to slow dpwn the rise. I would say I am up to 200 in about 30 minutes. A full basket of lump easily lasts 10 hours.


[ame="http://www.amazon.com/Eastwood-Pinpoint-Flame-Propane-Torch/dp/B006O9O548/ref=sr_1_15?s=power-hand-tools&ie=UTF8&qid=1360329503&sr=1-15"]Eastwood Pinpoint Flame Propane Torch : Amazon.com : Power & Hand Tools[/ame]

This isn't exactly my torch...but just the cheapest one at the hardware store...maybe 20 bucks. I love it!! Easy and fast
 
When I've used lump in my WSM I find really packing it in there and shaking the bottom to make it all settle closely together helps and have had pretty even burns with lump. It does burn faster and for longer cooks I have had to add more lump. Maybe a little more information on exactly what you are doing with the lump could help to diagnose the problem. In my egg lump is 100% the way to go as the ceramic really makes it last a long time and burn even more even because it is so much more insulated.

All that being said I use Kingsford briquettes 99% of the time in my WSM and like the results. Some use lump, some don't. Nothing wrong with using either so use what is easiest for you :grin:.
 
fnbish said:
When I've used lump in my WSM I find really packing it in there and shaking the bottom to make it all settle closely together helps and have had pretty even burns with lump. It does burn faster and for longer cooks I have had to add more lump. Maybe a little more information on exactly what you are doing with the lump could help to diagnose the problem. In my egg lump is 100% the way to go as the ceramic really makes it last a long time and burn even more even because it is so much more insulated.

All that being said I use Kingsford briquettes 99% of the time in my WSM and like the results. Some use lump, some don't. Nothing wrong with using either so use what is easiest for you :grin:.
Click to expand...

actually I should have mentioned that. I carefully layer the bottom and pack it tight with lump. I think that helps.
 
As you read thru the posts about lump and briquettes you'll find every opinion from A to Z. For me I think lump (name brand) has less quality control than briquettes. This could be from the increased interest in lump. We are a little behind in that area as the world has been using lump for hundreds of years. Also the backyard guy likes the convenience of briquettes. Just pour in a bag full throw on some gas and it's almost ready for the cheapest hot dogs. Briquettes are certainly more available and cost less than lump when the big box puts them on sale. So why use lump? I make my own so quality is not an issue. I like it in the Kamado for the even burn and less ash. But that's just another opinion in the loooong list.
 
I really want to hate the briqs, but I had a couple bags of KBB and they were the easiest, lowest maintenance cooks I've had. Tons more ash, though
 
I use lump (RO) in my WSM with no issues. I've done overnight cooks on it as well with no problems, and generally don't need to add any fuel for 10-12 hours.
I load up the ring with lump and some wood chunks, and add around 3/4 chimney of lit lump to the top, and it runs for 10+ hours with no trouble.
you should spend a few weekends doing all day cooks, sitting next to your cooker with a cooler full of beer...just to make sure you get the hang of it :wink:
 
I have to Call BS on Lump not lasting or doing well with the Minion method. I use lump in my UDS I have since the first burn 3 yrs ago 10 lb will go 20+ hrs. I use Lump in the Kettle with the ring of fire and get 16 hr burns at 275. You can BS a BSh*t'er but son you can't Snow the Iceman.
 
I also like a briquette/lump combo in my wsm's. It just burns cleaner if I dump ashed over briqs in a depression in the top of the unlit LUMP, but I often load a layer or two of "natural" briquettes on the bottom.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

S
Gas assist to the rescue!
Replies
3
Views
222
food4thot
food4thot
J
An Expensive Tube of Liquid Nails.......
Replies
11
Views
2K
1911Ron
1911Ron
C
Charcoal sales - B&B briquets vs. Cowboy
Replies
2
Views
997
dummy que
D
S
High-end pellet grill rec?
2
Replies
33
Views
1K
oldgfbbq
O
Headgear
I May Have Ruined Some Wood!
Replies
19
Views
1K
Headgear
Headgear
Back
Top