Pit Barrel Cooker

[PatioDaddio]

I've said it before, but I'll say it again. It's truly amazing that so many people will spend $500-$1000 of mental energy/gymnastics on a $225 decision. I sometimes imagine a dude standing in the grocery store calling several other stores to see if they can save a quarter on a loaf of bread.

John

[Pitmaster T]

Originally Posted by PatioDaddio

I've said it before, but I'll say it again. It's truly amazing that so many people will spend $500-$1000 of mental energy/gymnastics on a $225 decision. I sometimes imagine a dude standing in the grocery store calling several other stores to see if they can save a quarter on a loaf of bread.

John

No truer words have been spoken. It is the the number one reason to buy a PBC, BDS, D-Meat Barrel, Big Poppa Smoker; that someone else has done the big thinking or labor for you.



and no.... its too easy....




No..... I swore I wouldn't.............








its also a good reason to buy one of these...

[Ijustwantedtolookatpics]

Never thought I'd see a real doll on a BBQ forum!

[Beanbuzz]

Received my PBC yesterday and fired it up today. I guess I'll be one of the first to say I was pretty much disappointed with this thing. Hung a rack of baby backs and later added a whole chicken cut in half. Total cook time was 4 hrs. for the ribs and 2.5 hrs. for the chicken, as per instructions.
The ribs were way overcooked and dry with the end closest to the coals basically inedible. The chicken was not done . I had to part the chicken out and finish some pieces in the oven. I guess I got caught in all the hype about this thing ,but now I wish that I had waited to see more opinions.
As for ribs, I'll continue to use the 3.2.1. method on my BGE.

[Pitmaster T]

Originally Posted by Beanbuzz

Received my PBC yesterday and fired it up today. I guess I'll be one of the first to say I was pretty much disappointed with this thing. Hung a rack of baby backs and later added a whole chicken cut in half. Total cook time was 4 hrs. for the ribs and 2.5 hrs. for the chicken, as per instructions.
The ribs were way overcooked and dry with the end closest to the coals basically inedible. The chicken was not done . I had to part the chicken out and finish some pieces in the oven. I guess I got caught in all the hype about this thing ,but now I wish that I had waited to see more opinions.
As for ribs, I'll continue to use the 3.2.1. method on my BGE.

I am glad you felt so strongly that you signed on for the second time in your life to tell us how you felt. Last time (May)it was the electric shack, right.

The Egg is a keeper.

[PatioDaddio]

Originally Posted by Beanbuzz

Received my PBC yesterday and fired it up today. I guess I'll be one of the first to say I was pretty much disappointed with this thing. Hung a rack of baby backs and later added a whole chicken cut in half. Total cook time was 4 hrs. for the ribs and 2.5 hrs. for the chicken, as per instructions.
The ribs were way overcooked and dry with the end closest to the coals basically inedible. The chicken was not done . I had to part the chicken out and finish some pieces in the oven. I guess I got caught in all the hype about this thing ,but now I wish that I had waited to see more opinions.
As for ribs, I'll continue to use the 3.2.1. method on my BGE.

Four hours for lionbacks is too long for sure. Remember that in BBQ time is only a guideline. As for the chicken, I have no idea how 2.5 hours wasn't long enough. Large half chickens on mine typically take under two hours. What was the temp in the thigh? In other words, what is your definition of "done"? I go to about 155* in the breast and 165* in the thigh.

John

[sparky']

Half chickens take me a little over one hour. Ribs about two hours.

[Meat Man]

The PBC is a nice cooker, it's a small UDS.



Great for small cooks, and ultra portable.


The kids built a UDS using Big Poppas kit. The kit is very high quality, and very easy to assemble about 2 hours.


We liked the hanging aspect of the PBC, so we incorporated into our UDS.


I've cooked on both and the results are very similar. Hanging chickens is great, it's nice to be able to fit so many on a small or large UDS. You'll need to be careful with your large heavy meats, Not a fan of hanging ribs, wasn't impressed with how they turned out. Longer cuts like brisket and ribs get to done close to the fire. We liked the PBC cooks just great and super for transporting and small families. We use the BPS drum all the time. It's more versatile such as, adjustable fire basket height for grilling or BBQ, wider range of cooking temps, more room for larger groups or hungry kids.

[jrn]

[QUOTE=Meat Man;2319792]The PBC is a nice cooker, it's a small UDS.


I totally agree!
Thanks for the side by side comparisons.

[RangerJ]

Originally Posted by PatioDaddio

Yes, that's safe to assume. Again, give Noah a call. It's free and painless, I promise. He's a war veteran (and true hero), but he's gentle.

John

Been trying to ignore this thread for all the obvious reasons.

Still waiting for one to surface in the Houston MSA so I can truly see how different the meat tastes than my drums. But now my interest is truly piqued.

A "hero" you say...

[PatioDaddio]

Originally Posted by RangerJ

Been trying to ignore this thread for all the obvious reasons.

Still waiting for one to surface in the Houston MSA so I can truly see how different the meat tastes than my drums. But now my interest is truly piqued.

A "hero" you say...

Yup. Google is your friend.

John

[RangerJ]

Originally Posted by PatioDaddio

Yup. Google is your friend.

John

If its on the internet it must be true? I don't Google "hero's" wildman, I've walked among them.

You tossed it out here in a thread about a cooker, I'd expect you to explain.

Or don't...

[Trumpstylz]

Originally Posted by RangerJ

If its on the internet it must be true? I don't Google "hero's" wildman, I've walked among them.

You tossed it out here in a thread about a cooker, I'd expect you to explain.

Or don't...

Not sure if he has any ribbons or medals, but if the man's a veteran, I'd say he's a hero. Nuff said.

[RangerJ]

Originally Posted by Trumpstylz

Not sure if he has any ribbons or medals, but if the man's a veteran, I'd say he's a hero. Nuff said.

And like the rest of us, probably does not like that term tossed around. Nuff said.

[jeffsee]

Originally Posted by Meat Man

The PBC is a nice cooker, it's a small UDS.



Great for small cooks, and ultra portable.


The kids built a UDS using Big Poppas kit. The kit is very high quality, and very easy to assemble about 2 hours.


We liked the hanging aspect of the PBC, so we incorporated into our UDS.


I've cooked on both and the results are very similar. Hanging chickens is great, it's nice to be able to fit so many on a small or large UDS. You'll need to be careful with your large heavy meats, Not a fan of hanging ribs, wasn't impressed with how they turned out. Longer cuts like brisket and ribs get to done close to the fire. We liked the PBC cooks just great and super for transporting and small families. We use the BPS drum all the time. It's more versatile such as, adjustable fire basket height for grilling or BBQ, wider range of cooking temps, more room for larger groups or hungry kids.

Thanks to your post, I'm going to sell my 18.5" WSM, get the Big Poppa Smoker Kit, get a 55 gallon drum (have a line on a free one) drill the extra 4 holes for rebar, have that former student sandblast and powder coat it, and make the necessary adjustments in the intake to run at the higher temp when hanging.

Thanks for the info.