Thick TOUGH Pork Loin 'Chops" ... boneless ... not too great

Q

Q_Egg

Guest
All excited to get in another Traeger pellet cook ! Ran to Costco for terrific looking package of thick (~1 1/2in thick _ 3 in wide), boneless pork loin chops.
These chops have always been tough for us no matter how they have been cooked .... so also grabbed a Jaccard 16 tooth meat tenderizer. Punched the tenderizer as directed about 4-5 times across each chop ... on both sides .. ( I know .... you some of you guys warned me to get the 48-tooth Jaccard ).
Seasoned 4 of the chops with 4 different rubs .... D Pig, K Stone, D Klose, J Henry.

Started the Traeger (Apple .. bottom .. & .. Oak top pellets), chops went in at 180*F for 30 minutes. Cranked up temp to 325*F ... planning on around 45 more minutes. Internal temp hit 165*F within 30 more minutes. Sampled a chop on each end for internal temp. Digital temp readout on hopper end .. and .. dial thermometer on right-side lid .. both indicated close to the set temp (325*F).

Only ate two of these large chops, seasoning was OK ... maybe good, since it was definitely there, but not at all overpowering. Chops had attractive appearance, somewhat moist surface, not dry inside.

BUTTTT .... they were dang tufff !!! .... almost like I remember the previous chops that were not 'tenderized'. What the chit happened? Please give me some temp and times thoughts that would help make these chops more tender! I was concerned to cook too long, dry them out, and make them even tougher .... was I wrong? How about just 225*F throughout the cook until 165*F ? What about lots more Jaccard 'punches' (like 48 tooth)?

Can thick loin chops ever be tender ??

Dang frustrated!
 
Tom

I too have battled the Costco thick cuts, and my best method seems to be a reverse of your (low then high) method.

On the Kettle, I cook them direct over the coals (or on the gasser after heated up good) for a couple minutes per side (maybe 3 minutes each at 400* or more.

Then I move them to do indirect, covered, couple apple chunks in there, for about 30 minutes at 250* or so.

But its still a crap shoot. I will end up with very tender and moist chops, or tough, but still moist chops.

Its pretty rare that I cook them lately, without slitting a pocket into them and stuffin them. They are just too darned thick on their own
 
willkat98 said:
Tom

I too have battled the Costco thick cuts, and my best method seems to be a reverse of your (low then high) method. ..................

Its pretty rare that I cook them lately, without slitting a pocket into them and stuffin them. They are just too darned thick on their own
Click to expand...
--------------------------------

Sort of a 'seared' steak approach .... I will need to shift over to the BGE to cook that hot, but will definitly give it a try. It's helpful to know that you have experienced the same difficulty.

I'm also going to give the Jaccard one more try ... on the remaining 4 chops ... with more punches to emulate the 48-tooth version. If no real imptovement, then it goes back since this is precisely what I purchased it for.

Many thanks
 
I have really never had a pork chop even worth eating. (Thick ones)They are just too lean. You can season and marinate them for eternity, but they are always dry or tough.
That's why I always go for what they call shoulder or blade steaks, much more flavor and marbling.
JMO
 
... wifey is a great wok cook (a bit OT) and those blade steaks are her pork of choice for many stir friy dishes.

I'm finding that pork butt is so versatile that it (and ribs) are my reliable choice for piggy Q. So much for those very tempting looking big packs of thick chops !!
 
The key words are "boneless", "loin" and "chops". With no bone, low fat content, and no mass (like a whole loin would have) these babies are hard to cook.

Try flavor brining for 4 hours in the refrigerator. Use a zipper bag or submerge in a non-reactive container (corning ware, tupperware etc.) This is a basic starter flavor brine. It is not as strong as a curing brine.

1 ½ quarts water
3 tablespoons coarse Kosher salt (Morton's)
3 tablespoons brown sugar
2 teaspooons rub

Edit: Added "Morton's" brand.
 
Last edited:
I had thicker (not Costco monsters) pork chops last night.

I broke the handle off one of my frying pans smashing the chops down to about a 1/3", then breaded and threw in a pan with peanut oil.

Maybe after using the jacquard, go a round or two with the bottom of a cast iron pan (in wax/parchment paper first)
 
thirdeye said:
Try flavor brining for 4 hours in the refrigerator. Use a zipper bag or submerge in a non-reactive container (corning ware, tupperware etc.) This is a basic starter flavor brine. It is not as strong as a curing brine.
Click to expand...
Sounds like a winner for my remaining 4 thick chops. If it is 'sensational' then I'll hang in there with these chops .... otherwise I'm going to BUTT out.

Thanks for the flavor brine formula. I really need to get some expereince with brining anyway.

Regards,
 
As Thirdeye said, brine those babies! I think four hours might be too long, but that's up to personal taste. i usually brine thick chops for about 90 minutes. My brine is basically the same as Thirdeye's, but I usually add some soy sauce.

Then I grill them the same as i do steaks: Seared on both sides for two minutes or so, and then finished indirect until 145 or 150 internal. Then they rest for 5-10 minutes while we assemble the rest of the meal. As others pointed out, today's pork is vey lean, so it will dry out if you cook it too long. Today's pork is also safe to eat at lower temperatures, so you really don't need to cook them to 165.

Also, I won't buy boneless chops. If I can't get bone-in loin chops that are at least 1" thick I'll go someplace else.
 
Can't remember the last time we bought a chop. I'll buy a whole loin at Sam's and slice. Season with Gordon's GrubRub and let them sit for an hour or two. I usually grill them, but they do OK in the smoker at 225-250.
 
Ron_L said:
As Thirdeye said, brine those babies! I think four hours might be too long, but that's up to personal taste. i usually brine thick chops for about 90 minutes. My brine is basically the same as Thirdeye's, but I usually add some soy sauce.

Then I grill them the same as i do steaks: Seared on both sides for two minutes or so, and then finished indirect until 145 or 150 internal. Then they rest for 5-10 minutes while we assemble the rest of the meal. As others pointed out, today's pork is vey lean, so it will dry out if you cook it too long. Today's pork is also safe to eat at lower temperatures, so you really don't need to cook them to 165.

Also, I won't buy boneless chops. If I can't get bone-in loin chops that are at least 1" thick I'll go someplace else.
Click to expand...

A standard ratio of Kosher salt to water is 3 tablespoons per quart of water so this brine is a little weaker. My brine times for regular thickness chops is at least two hours, but I figured if Tom's are 1-1/2" the brine time may need to be closer to 4 hours. Tom ... Maybe brining some for only 2 hours to use as a comparison is a good idea here?

BTW, it's a good time to remind that sizes of grains of kosher salts vary which means a cup of one brand does not weigh the same as a cup of another so it's best to stick with one brand. 1 cup of Mortons is 7-3/4 ounces and a cup of Diamond is only 5 ounces. This difference alone will make a big difference in the strength of a brine.
 
Ron_L said:
As Thirdeye said, brine those babies! I think four hours might be too long, but that's up to personal taste. i usually brine thick chops for about 90 minutes. My brine is basically the same as Thirdeye's, but I usually add some soy sauce.

Then I grill them the same as i do steaks: Seared on both sides for two minutes or so, and then finished indirect until 145 or 150 internal. Then they rest for 5-10 minutes while we assemble the rest of the meal. As others pointed out, today's pork is vey lean, so it will dry out if you cook it too long. Today's pork is also safe to eat at lower temperatures, so you really don't need to cook them to 165.

Also, I won't buy boneless chops. If I can't get bone-in loin chops that are at least 1" thick I'll go someplace else.
Click to expand...

Brine-90mins max
Cook-140 to 145
1" thick bone in

Ron you hit a home run on this one, this is the way I do it. Yes, we do have a tough chop now and then but mostly they are tender.

You get what you pay for, if you are lucky enough to have a tender chop and it's cheap be happy.
 
To get them fork tender you have to braise them. After you get some smoke on them either foil them or put them in a covered casserole dish with some liquid like apple juice or some riesling wine.
 
Good points, Thirdeye... With soy sauce in my brine it does have a higher salt content. As always, YMMV!

Also, Here's a great recipe for thick pork chops. It is a little involved, but it is wonderful! (The link is to a .pdf file). The recipe is from The Embers restaurant in Mt. Pleasant, Michigan. It's a nice place if you are ever in that area (BBQBull... it's not too far from you).
 
I appreciate this all-around guidance ...

The point about brands of kosher salt makes me 'pay attention' since I always have two large boxes of kosher around (Mortons and North American Salt Co .... Walmart). They are very different grain/texture and I use them for very different purposes.

Now I have several variables to play with ..... which makes for some interesting future cooks. Brining (different times and concentrations); more Jaccard 'punches'; a little of both; some braising; find bone-on chops; a great-sounding Embers recipe; order more pellets! :biggrin:
 
I split them in half (on the edge) to make two pork chops. I season with rub, dip them in an eggwash and then in bread crumbs. Then I fry those bad boys. Crunchy on the outside, tender and juicy on the inside. Serve em with some rice and gravy and buttered green beans and get happy!
 
I think your whole problem is that you're overcooking them. Take them off at 140, put them on a plate, cover it with foil and let them rest for 10 minutes. It's OK if they're a little pink. Even if there was trichinosis in domestic pork (there isn't) it would be killed at 137. Pink is good.
 
i do like the Doc says..

I never bring those Costco chops beyond med-rare. To be specific, I put them in a microwave on low to med low for about 30 seconds to get the chill out(I dont like leaving them out to get to room temp). So a quick nuke warms them a bit.

Then a seer on both sides on a hot grill,

and move them to the warming rack or to and offset spot and fisnish them there.

Remove just under 140 and let them rest loosely covered.

last batch i made, i let them rest right in their serving plates for about 5 minutes then I covered them with hot applesauce just before ringing the dinner bell.
 
They are just like ribs - you can't get them tender without boiling them. :smile: Just ask my MIL. :roll:

Actually, I agree with some of the posts above. Sear them first - even in a frying pan - before they go in the smoker. Then smoke them to araound 145 to 150 and rest.
 
Ron L, Ive ate their a few times. Its about an hours drive from here. Have you eaten their?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

J
How do you make tender pork chops?
2
Replies
35
Views
3K
thirdeye
thirdeye
S
Buckboard ham
2
Replies
24
Views
727
stickman
S
Fatback Joe
Dry Aged Pork Chop
Replies
12
Views
489
Fatback Joe
Fatback Joe
Moose
• Savory Fire-Grilled Spicy Apple Seasoned Pork Loin Chops Cooked Over Hot Hickory Coals
Replies
10
Views
460
oldgfbbq
O
sudsandswine
Maple bourbon pork tenderloin
Replies
17
Views
1K
Smoking Piney
Smoking Piney
Back
Top