Watkins seems to be the only 'true' extract. One other outfit I searched had syrup or flavoring (less intense). Watkins is a small ~2 oz bottle. That is the taste that really comes through with each slice end-to-end.
Both of those hams looked real good to me. I think that the final product needs to look good in order to taste good. It's like getting a good first impression.
A buddy of mine worked for Honey Baked Ham Co many moons ago during the holiday rush. He told me that if you want a good glaze on your ham, you need to use a torch, that is how they did it.
.... Hmmm .... the decision looms close ?? All the best ... and regards to our leader ... Dr BBQ . It's sometimes hard to really know how tough it is to be the trailblazer.
Sorry, but it's almost New Year's and I get sentimental .....