• working on DNS.. links may break temporarily.

My lesson Learned in BBQ Rubs Home made vs Commercially made

IamMadMan

somebody shut me the fark up.
Joined
Jul 30, 2011
Messages
14,879
Reaction score
18,993
Points
0
Location
Pemberton, New Jersey
I know we all discuss rub recipes and discuss which is best from time to time. Here is my newest lesson I have learned.

I used to make my own rubs using a commercial mixer, but found inconsistencies in the spice products ordered from distributors. I found that because I did not have a laboratory to test the incoming products, I was at the peril of my suppliers and what they shipped to me in bulk form was not consistent. I had made rubs for over 10 years never reaching the apex I was looking for. I used the best and freshest products available, but there was always something lacking in the balance of flavors.

5 years ago I decided to go to a commercially prepared rub which I could pick up locally in large bulk packaging. This was the key to my consistency. This worked well and I was happy without reservation. We are all familiar with the saying "Why fix what is not broken?"

However my son is going into the military and we had planned a surprise party to congratulate him on his choices in life and wish him well as he departs us to serve his country. I tried the Oakridge Competition Rub on the ribs and on the pork butts. Simply put Oakrige hit the ball out of the park. My hats off to them with a GREAT product, I'm sorry I didn't try it sooner, clearly it was my loss.

At first I was not crazy with the idea of trying something new. I think we get locked into this same frame of mind. When the opportunity allows, I think we should all let our guard down and try something new from time to time. My only opposition now is that many rubs are not available in bulk.

I urge those who are new to BBQ to try some of the commercial rubs available in the small packaging. I wish I had tried some of these when my cooks were smaller, it would have helped me in so many other ways.

I will probably have some opposition here, but in the end I think it is best to leave the rubs to the professional suppliers. They buy in extreme bulk at discounts, they have professional mixing and measuring equipment. In the end they have the quality control labs to provide you with a consistent product that will not change from cook to cook. It will save you a lot of work, effort, and some money in the interim, and there are so many choices out there.

I look forward to expanding my horizons on smaller family cooks in the future as I try some of the many other choices that await me as I experiment.
 
Last edited:
Hmm...interesting.
I've not been smoking very long, but have used commercial rubs so far. The main reason, is that I lack the appropriate spices in the quantities needed for rubbing a couple butts.

I've been wanting to buy the bulk spices since day one, but haven't "gotten there yet".

That being said, I have wanted to try the SM rub you mentioned, just because of the shear amount of recommendations I've heard here. Maybe I'll not worry so much about making my own.

Good thread.
 
I love SMR they are great rubs. đź‘Ť


Have fun and happy smoking
BBQ UP
 
Hmm...interesting.
I've not been smoking very long, but have used commercial rubs so far. The main reason, is that I lack the appropriate spices in the quantities needed for rubbing a couple butts.

I've been wanting to buy the bulk spices since day one, but haven't "gotten there yet".

That being said, I have wanted to try the SM rub you mentioned, just because of the shear amount of recommendations I've heard here. Maybe I'll not worry so much about making my own.

Good thread.

From my experience, by the time you buy in bulk, take the time to weigh and mix the spices, test it, and vac-pac to keep it fresh....

You really don't save money by doing it yourself.. Add the cost of the spices, the time required to process them (time is money), and you have saved nothing. Yes it is a fun experiment and the outcome can be good. I have tried over 100 recipes and even varied them from time to time, but never anything outstanding.

Try a rub in the commercial market and if you like it buy it in 5 lb packs for the best price. If you grow larger you can even buy 25 lb boxes from some vendors.. Not sure if SM offers these large sizes though.

.
 
I have come to the same conclusion about making sausage.

Unless its a simple recipe, I perfer to buy pre mixed spices.
 
Ok, I'm good with that, but the question that begs to be asked......
"WHY" are they better?
What makes them better than ours? Is it a secret ingredient, is it the "perfect" combination of spices?
We can buy quality product, just like they can, so I'm not buying the theory that they're getting better stuff. Not by much anyway.
 
I always made my own rubs which usually come out pretty good but not perfect but still I felt that if i didnt make the rub or injection than it really wasnt my bbq but a few weeks ago i ordered a sample pack from dizzy pig and liked them better than my own so i went went ahead and placed an order for some other rubs from other vendors.
 
How about the rub used by the # 1 Team in the nation. 3 Eyz Rub. Says something when you can use what the best are using.
 
Ok, I'm good with that, but the question that begs to be asked......
"WHY" are they better?
What makes them better than ours? Is it a secret ingredient, is it the "perfect" combination of spices?
We can buy quality product, just like they can, so I'm not buying the theory that they're getting better stuff. Not by much anyway.

In my case, I think one reason is they use fresher and more consistent ingredients.

I find that I may make a certain rub to try, and have to buy some off the wall spice I have no other use for.

So, if I am not crazy about that rub, the spice just sits there unused, getting stale and old.

I may pull it out later and use it on something else, it might be good or it might not.

Its just a lot of expense to try something new I may or may not like, and have some oddball spices left over if I dont like it.

I have some now that I should probably throw out and make room for others

I have some basic rubs that use common ingredients that I make all the time, for those it makes sense.
 
Ok, I'm good with that, but the question that begs to be asked......
"WHY" are they better?
What makes them better than ours? Is it a secret ingredient, is it the "perfect" combination of spices?
We can buy quality product, just like they can, so I'm not buying the theory that they're getting better stuff. Not by much anyway.

Why are they better?

They're not

It's a crapshoot...just like BBq Comp contests are.

What you might like.........another person doesn't.

It's the same for everything......cars. clothes, cities, food, weather, etc

Quality doesn't always mean why ppl buy or like something........look at all
the low end crap that is purchased every day

Freshness?......I just bought some rub that has an exp date of June 2016.

It's just a matter of individual tastes.

No need to over analyze this one.

See ya at the dolla store...cuz that "great" rub will be there someday.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have tried a handful of commercially made rubs and have tried a few from the books (Myron's, Gibson, Wicked Good BBQ, etc) ... and found a few I do like. However I still make my own for the special cooks.

I grow a lot of my own spices and hot peppers so I am pretty good with consistency and tweaking to get the flavor I want.

With that said though - commercial mixes are awesome (not all) but a few that I like. They save time and allow me to conserve my personal rubs for events I want them for.

Pork Pulling Plowboys
Simply Marvelous
Slappy Your Daddy (chicken)
and a few others...
 
For me I have always made my own rubs. However spices do go stale even if they are vacuum packed. I don't think I can get spices fresher than the big boys just because of quantity. Especially this time of year those rubs will just sit there waiting for fair weather. Cost sure you can make your own cheaper than buying the ready made. I put a mark on the lid of one of Emerill's rubs last spring and the bottle is still on the shelf. I am going to switch to ready made rubs from one or more of the sponsors of this site. I and my guests want the best so a few bucks wont make any difference to me.
 
Problem I found with a lot of (not all) commercial rubs is that the first ingredient is salt. I understand salt can make some foods taste better but usually there a bit to salty. I made my same rub for years and always came in second or third with ribs then last year I decided to make a new one. I was cooking pork loin for a friends wedding reception and when I opened the smoker I knew I had hit the mark with this rub. The next weekend we did a comp and finally nailed first place with our ribs. Also we were vending pulled pork and had many many comments of how our pulled pork was so much better than the rest of the teams. I will admit you have to use the freshest spices you can find and I also understand it's up to individual taste. You have to think of what taste profile your looking for I think. Not to say there is anything wrong with commercial rubs because there isn't I just think when I'm at a comp. I want everything to be from MY recipes including rubs and sauces. But that's just my opinion.
 
I just enjoy mixing up my own rubs. It's fun to try different combinations of spices and flavors and then see what the reactions are from friends and family. Some turn out great...some not so great...
 
What you call a professional supplier is just a step above your own abilities. I doubt ANY of the BBQ food suppliers not named 'Kraft" or its equals have quality control labs much more than an accurate scale. That said, it is helpful to find a commercial product you like and tweak it - just keep a record. What distinguishes 'the BBQ layperson' from the pro is not much more than his stuff is available for sale.
 
I'm not even gonna get into the "which is better" discussion... taste is so subjective.

What I don't understand is the need to purchase in bulk. For my own personal use I don't need pounds and pounds of the stuff. I mix my rubs up at about 1 cup at the time.
 
Back
Top