I cooked it a little longer than I wanted to, but it still was really good.
I agree... A little more done than I like, but it still looks great. I'm assuming that you're cooking on a Weber Kettle. When I cook steaks on my kettle I build the fire on one side of the grill and get it as hot as I can. then I sear the steaks over the fire for two minutes on a side and then move them to the other side of the grill to finish. medium rare for a one inch steak is about 6 minutes on a side after the sear, but it depends on the steak and how hot it is on the indirect side.
Ya did good bro...I like that garlic, evoo, lemon pepper marinade you did!