Well, I gotta admit - you guys have gotten me to re-thinkin. That is, I think I'm going to try the Dr. Pepper mop on a briskett. In fact, I've got a bottle of DP syrup that I bought at the museum in Waco. It's everything BUT the carbonated water if I remember correctly.
Regarding rubs, etc.. I tried a lot of them, on a lot of things, but always end up thinking salt & pepper only is better. I suppose there is an exception - once in a while I'll inject rosemary garlic into a pork loin which is pretty good. I'm going to try the DP mop though. Seems like I did many many moons ago but that was before all the mods. I may have associated the wrong cause with the effect. Like Pop always said, "BBQ is a very inexact science."
Believe it or not, I was big into rubs for a while then ol' Unka Pete told me, "Good meat don't need nothing but good wood, and the two oldest spices in the world. Heck, they's even black men in Dallas doin' that stuff (rubs) now. Don't make no sense at'tal."
For you rubbers out there.... I don't at all aim to convert any of you. However, next time you're cooking two pieces of the same meat, do one however you wish and one with pepper (and salt if it has a bone) and ask your guests which piece they like better without telling them wich piece is which. They may like yours bettter!
Maybe it's my family or the state of Oklahoma, but 100% of the time they vote for salt $ pepper. Heck, I'll try a mop, you try S&P. We may both learn something :wink:
With all the quotes on Q'in, I'll close with my own, "The proof is the meat. Nothing else."
- LeeBo