ModelMaker
Quintessential Chatty Farker
- Joined
- Apr 21, 2006
- Messages
- 5,604
- Reaction score
- 8,719
- Points
- 113
- Location
- Lake Ponderosa-Montezuma, IA
While keeping up with the BOD threads, discussions at contests, input from cook teams, one of the constant bones of contention is those damn judges and the lack of consistency between all of us.
I have given some thought to the problem (?) for some time now and have a couple suggestions to perhaps improve the perceived problems.
BOD candidates are touting continued education for the masses which I would look forward to, but how to implement it? One thought is since ALL CBJ's have to be active KCBS members and each have a renew date, why not incorporate a 10 - 15 question yearly test dealing with straightforward questions dealing with the KCBS rules and procedures (not like that goofy ass Masters test). Pass it you may judge next year, fail and not pass a second time, no card-no judge next year.
Secondly, since all CBJ's receive the Bullsheet why not use this platform to give a monthly topic of current issues to give all the CBJ's the same clarification at one time.
Third, have you ever read through the Rep advisory section at KCBS website? Anytime there is a major problem that requires a BOD decision it is added to the advisory vs a hard change in rule wording. Is there some reason a advisory section can't be set up for Judging problems?
Maybe it's being addressed now as it is and only needs to be presented to the masses more easily.
To me personally, a monthly Bullsheet column dealing with a current issue or rule, or action affecting judges and judging procedures that have a solution approved by the BOD would go a long way towards putting everybody on the same page and improve consistence, maybe.
Ed
I have given some thought to the problem (?) for some time now and have a couple suggestions to perhaps improve the perceived problems.
BOD candidates are touting continued education for the masses which I would look forward to, but how to implement it? One thought is since ALL CBJ's have to be active KCBS members and each have a renew date, why not incorporate a 10 - 15 question yearly test dealing with straightforward questions dealing with the KCBS rules and procedures (not like that goofy ass Masters test). Pass it you may judge next year, fail and not pass a second time, no card-no judge next year.
Secondly, since all CBJ's receive the Bullsheet why not use this platform to give a monthly topic of current issues to give all the CBJ's the same clarification at one time.
Third, have you ever read through the Rep advisory section at KCBS website? Anytime there is a major problem that requires a BOD decision it is added to the advisory vs a hard change in rule wording. Is there some reason a advisory section can't be set up for Judging problems?
Maybe it's being addressed now as it is and only needs to be presented to the masses more easily.
To me personally, a monthly Bullsheet column dealing with a current issue or rule, or action affecting judges and judging procedures that have a solution approved by the BOD would go a long way towards putting everybody on the same page and improve consistence, maybe.
Ed