• working on DNS.. links may break temporarily.

I made some Authentic Philly Cheesesteaks a while back, 56k warning, prOn overload!

fingerlickin'

Quintessential Chatty Farker
Joined
Jul 8, 2010
Messages
5,858
Reaction score
6,426
Points
0
Age
48
Location
Boyertown, PA
So now that Bigabyte managed to erect his poll. I figure it's about time I start shamefully pimpin' my wares. I figure with all of the other outstanding entries over in the Cheesesteak TD I may need to grovel a bit for some votes. So here's what I hope is some enticing prOn of some darn good sandwiches inspired by the Philly originals.

You can see the other entries and cast your vote here.



It all started a couple weeks ago when I was sitting at Citizens Bank Park catching a Phills game. So I'm sitting there eating my Schmitter and John Mayberry Jr. comes up to the plate. I look up at the scoreboard and lo and behold, he's from...where else, but Overland Fark, KS. Now this say's Overland Park but I'm sure they just misspelled Fark. :wink:

Mayberry.png


Now on with the rest of my inspiration. There's a local pub called McNally's that invented a sandwich called the Schmitter which is also sold in the Eagles and Phillies stadiums. Now it's a great sandwich, although it's getting kind of expensive, $9 these days, it was $6.50 when the park opened and my last one was looking kind of sad. :tsk:

IMAG0251.jpg


Most would think it's named after Phillies Hall of Fame third baseman, Mike Schmidt, but that's not the case, it's actually named after a beer. The famed Schmidt's beer. :tsk: In any event, I decided to make my version at home for you guys and gals, along with a couple other REAL Philly versions of a cheesesteak.

My original plan was to cook these on my OTS on my cast iron griddle, unfortunately the griddle was too big for the OTS, but luckily I have an XL egg sitting right beside it. :grin: I fired up some Humprey's lump charcoal and had at it.

IMG_3503.jpg


Here are the ingredients, you can disregard the chicken steaks in the back, I ran out of time before the Eagles game, and those will have to wait for next time. For the Schmitter I bought a nice looking Ribeye and murdered it on my meat slicer into semi-thin slices. The other pile of meat is hand sliced choice beef from the butcher in the local farmers market. Yep, that is Cheez Whiz in the back, we'll get to that later. :becky:

IMG_3496.jpg


Here's the murdered Ribeye.

Fark! The picture is supposed to be right here but for some reason it's not showing up, you can see the murdered Ribeye 2 pics down. Maybe it'll show up eventually, I've edited it so many times maybe 10 of them will show up. :doh:

I made up the special sauce for the Schmitter, it's something along the lines of Thousand Island I believe. So I just went with this. Ketchup, Mayo, chopped pickles, pickle juice and some woosty sauce.

IMG_3502.jpg


These babies cook pretty quick so I assembled everything out by the grill.

IMG_3512.jpg


Now for the bread, they do sell Amoroso's rolls in my grocery store, although the woman in front of me bought all of them as I stood there and watched. :tsk: No matter though, there is a great Italian bakery right down the road called Corropolese so I made a trip over there for a dozen steak rolls and a dozen medium kaiser's. The best part about these rolls is the soft center, man I love these things.

IMG_3510.jpg


IMG_3509.jpg


Then the action started. A pile of sliced onions and the Ribeye went on the grill.

IMG_3515.jpg


IMG_3516.jpg


Some fried Salami.

IMG_3519.jpg


Now onto assembly, the Schmitter starts with the bottom bun, then cheese, steak meat, onions, tomatoes, more cheese, fried Salami, special sauce, and finally more cheese, and the top bun, American cheese BTW. Here's how it went down.

IMG_3520.jpg

IMG_3521.jpg

IMG_3522.jpg

IMG_3523.jpg


Yep, it's a whole lotta awesome.

IMG_3524.jpg


So for my next trick, I figured since I was going over to a friends for the Birds game, I'd pack some cheesesteaks for the peeps. Today we had Whiz Wit, and some suburban variety cheesesteaks, around my house most people like them with American, onions, and sauce. I also made no onion versions for the crazy people.

There is always a debate about chopped vs. sliced steak, I like them both and here we're doing chopped. I guess you could say I like Pat's more than Geno's, although neither of them are really the best you can find.

4lbs of razor thin steak.

IMG_3530.jpg


Diced onions.

IMG_3531.jpg


Meat.

IMG_3532.jpg


Sauce and onions.

IMG_3539.jpg


Whiz. (Note: When using Whiz it's important to warm it up before you spread it on the bun. I heated mine on the stove in a water bath, but the microwave works too. At a lot of steak joints they'll just sit the can on the flat top all day.)

IMG_3534.jpg


Wit.

IMG_3535.jpg


Here's some of them spread out at the party.

IMG_3541.jpg


Schmitter, it get's all melty, and messier after it sits wrapped up in foil for a bit.

IMG_3540.jpg


Whiz Wit for me.

IMG_3543.jpg


and the obligatory cute kids shot, the party was a huge success, including a big 1pt win by the Eagles. :thumb:

IMG_3552.jpg


I'm torn over the money shot. Maybe Al can decide for me between these two.

IMG_3524.jpg


IMG_3543.jpg


Thank for looking.

:peace:
 
Dayum fine sammie!! Your post in the TD inspired us to convert Alex's B.O.M.B. burger into a philly-style sandwich.

That schmitter looks like the schit!! Had some neighbors that moved to PA...might hafta go visit them.

And it's named after the legendary schmidt beer!!?? OMG...do you know how many "sport pack attacks" I had during high school/college?? Oh man, the "animal" beer...
 
Please Please Please dont use the wit. Awesome post till you put the Wit in Love the steaks There are few things better than a good cheese steak- I like provolone You made me really hungry:hungry::hungry::hungry::hungry:
 
Wow Jason!! I haven't looked at the other entries but yours looks like a winner for sure!! Danged fine job. :grin:
 
:shocked:

:hail:

Absolutely fanfarkingtastic right there! :clap2: Great post, great grub, great pix! :thumb:

I'm gonna have to look into this Philly Cheesesteak thingee...:hungry:
 
Thank you for the complements everyone!

There's only one thing wrong here...I'm loosing to an Australian and a guy from California! Help me people, go vote please, oh the shame, the shame! :tsk:
 
Wow! Both of those sandwiches awesome, I'll take two of each!
 
Looks good! I'm with some of the others on cheez whiz though- authentic or not, I don't get into liquid cheese!


Thanks J-Rod, but have you ever had a cheesesteak with cheez whiz? It's pretty darned good, you just have to put the fact that it's a "cheese product" out of your mind. Then you'll feel much better. (no, not really):tsk: Truth be told, while I do love the wiz, I only get it when I get a steak in the city, even then it's only on occasion that I don't get american or provolone.
 
Back
Top