St Louis Cut ribs vs whole spares

T

tbone30349

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 30, 2013
Messages
29
Reaction score
7
Points
0
Location
Atlanta, GA
Greetings and a thousand blessings to each and every one of you, my good people. Quick question. Which do u prefer, St Louis cut ribs or whole spares? I'm accustomed to buying and cooking whole spares, but haven't bought a slab of st Louis yet. What do yall prefer? Also, what about baby backs? I prefer spares over BB. What about yourselves?

Keep the mind attuned to a positive frequency


Byrd Man
 
I prefer to buy whole spares and them trim them to St. Louis cut myself and cook the ribs and tips/trim separately, or sometimes just cook the ribs and freeze the rest for another time, make sausage, etc.
 
I buy whole spares over baby backs, but I trim them to St. Louis cuts. I prefer it because it cooks more evenly, and eats easier (no fussing with the cartilage when eating it). I do cook the trimmings the same time I cook the ribs for some snacks since they finish before the ribs do.
 
I don't have a preference specifically as here it is kinda buy what you find that looks halfway decent.

That said, I like getting full spares and trimming. Rib Ends are awesome have quite a few uses (one of my favorites is using it in pork and beans).
 
Add another to everything said above - the racks already trimmed up seem to be quite a bit more expensive than the full racks plus you get the rib tips to cook after you've trimmed them up. I like to cook the tips in chili made in the slow cooker.
 
I always go for full spares at about $2.49lb vs. St. Louie's at around $3.99lb. Trim em up St louie style and save the trimmings for other stuff. Takes more prep time, but getting more meat for less dough is always a good thing.
 
Presh8 the responses, all of which make perfectly good sense. I've only trimmed em once, but I think I'm gonna make it a habit
 
I like buying spares and triming them down to St. Louis cuts myself. I have the worst time with crazy crooked bones when I buy St. Louis cuts pre cut. The last St. Louis cut I got from RD had bones I swear were shaped like an "S".

I wish I knew a better way to tell about the bones.
 
Personally, I prefer spares to BB. For the money, just not enough meat on the bone for BB. I like to buy whole spares and trim them down to St. Louis myself. I will cook the St. L and rib tips seperately, usually giving the tips to the neighborhood kids....
 
I trim the spares myself and give the leftover cuts to my wife for spaghetti sauce.
 
Yup, I'm with the majority. Buy the whole rack and trim it yourself before or after your cook. I'm an after guy as I love riblets. Plus the price is so much better. Whole spares are $1.68/lb on sale where I'm at, while St. Louis are usually around 2.99/lb. That's almost double the price for a 30 second trim job and 1/3 less meat.

Buy a whole rack, flip it over and find where the bones meet the cartilage (it's really easy to see) and run your knife all the way down. Done and done.
 
I prefer untrimmed spares.

I would rather have loin back ribs than St. Louis ribs.
 
jamus34 said:
I don't have a preference specifically as here it is kinda buy what you find that looks halfway decent.

That said, I like getting full spares and trimming. Rib Ends are awesome have quite a few uses (one of my favorites is using it in pork and beans).
Click to expand...

^^that
 
I usually end up getting St Louis cuts but last couple times I've been able to get Full Spares for decent price. Been learning and practicing the art of the trim to St Louis (not as easy as it sounds if you've not done it before) and giving my wife the left over meats for her Filipino dishes. Works out better in the long run.

1. Cheaper
2. More Meat
3. Different meals
4. Plus if you ever make it on Pitmasters you'll be able to trim your ribs up. LOL
 
I think you should trim to St Louis. People eat with their eyes first.

Today went to a local BBQ restaurant that trims their ribs to St Louis cuts. A full slab is priced at $20.99, which is competitive. Then the "rib tips" are priced at $6.99 per pound. There is always a sign in the store that advertises the rib tips "while they last". And they hawk the product as the best deal in the house. The pitmaster gets a better looking product, gets a more even cook across the more uniform sized slab, plus increases his net revenue per slab. And there is probably only 2 minutes per slab of extra labor in both the trimming and cooking of the rib tips.
 
Know Bull said:
I think you should trim to St Louis. People eat with their eyes first.

Today went to a local BBQ restaurant that trims their ribs to St Louis cuts. A full slab is priced at $20.99, which is competitive. Then the "rib tips" are priced at $6.99 per pound. There is always a sign in the store that advertises the rib tips "while they last". And they hawk the product as the best deal in the house. The pitmaster gets a better looking product, gets a more even cook across the more uniform sized slab, plus increases his net revenue per slab. And there is probably only 2 minutes per slab of extra labor in both the trimming and cooking of the rib tips.
Click to expand...


Great breakdown
 
tbone30349 said:
Greetings and a thousand blessings to each and every one of you, my good people. Quick question. Which do u prefer, St Louis cut ribs or whole spares? I'm accustomed to buying and cooking whole spares, but haven't bought a slab of st Louis yet. What do yall prefer? Also, what about baby backs? I prefer spares over BB. What about yourselves?

Keep the mind attuned to a positive frequency


Byrd Man
Click to expand...

Where do you buy your whole spares in Atlanta?
 
As many have said, I like whole spares and trim to st louis. I cook the trimmings along with them to experiment on myself any odd rubs and whatnot......and just to have something to snack on along the way. I hate wasting anything I pay for.
 
I agree with everyone else. Buy the spares and trim them yourself. I cook the tips and ST. Louis styles at the same time.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

N
"Chud style" direct heat spares
Replies
16
Views
2K
TheHojo
TheHojo
bowhnter
Butt n ribs
Replies
9
Views
447
snadamo
snadamo
F
Weird St. Louis ribs at BJs wholesale
Replies
3
Views
1K
1MoreFord
1MoreFord
B
Cook times, St. Louis ribs vs baby backs?
Replies
13
Views
1K
ModelMaker
ModelMaker
T
Full Spares - A Rarity No Longer
2
Replies
26
Views
5K
Smoke Dawg
Smoke Dawg
Back
Top