It was my understanding that in order to be a Jack Qualifier the event has to be open to anyone and that requiring any type of membership to enter disqualifies those events.
I have heard this said several times, but never read anything to confirm it asside from hearsay. If I look at Jack Daniel's website, they don't have their rules posted. The closest official thing I have ever found is this:
http://www.jackdaniels.com/happenings/current-happenings.aspx?id=106
Some one else has posted the 2010 rules here:
http://www.slapyodaddybbq.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/2010-10-23-Jack-Daniels-Appl1.pdf
I have seen a similar list of 2011 rules, and saw no signifigant change. Nowhere is it said that an event must be open to the the general public. Even still, as has been pointed out, these events are open to the general public since KCBS membership is open to the general public. Of course, a literal reading of the rules doesn't prohibit invitationals, does it?
I know some people will find it heretical of me to say this, but I think it's really bad form for BF to not publish the bung and automatic qualification rules where all can see them. Worse yet, there have been other rules brought to the public which are not detailed in the referenced documents. Sure, B-F could claim that there is a rule that you state, and there may well be one, but it's not publically available. If you know of a documented rule, I'd love to see it.
For the record, the AR does make their qualification rules public, and they don't state that contests are required to be public either.
http://www.americanroyal.com/Default.aspx?tabid=236
Interestingly to me, the both sets of rules specifically require the govenor to sign a proclamation, though I have been told that some state legislatures issue proclamations. These would not qualify according to the strict letter....
dmp