• working on DNS.. links may break temporarily.

Another shot at brisket

Dockman

Got Wood.
Joined
Jan 25, 2013
Messages
40
Reaction score
4
Points
0
Location
Climax Springs, Mo
Time to try a brisket on the MES 40! Going to marinade it for 24-36 hours with coke, bbq sauce, and make some A1 or woshershire. Then for rub I plan to use salt, pepper, and steak rub! Going to smoke with cherry for 12 at 200-225 or how ever long it takes.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    70.1 KB · Views: 383
Nice hunk of meat, you sure are going fancy with that marinade. Best of luck, I am gonna bet longer than 12 hours at those temps.
 
Time to try a brisket on the MES 40! Going to marinade it for 24-36 hours with coke, bbq sauce, and make some A1 or woshershire. Then for rub I plan to use salt, pepper, and steak rub! Going to smoke with cherry for 12 at 200-225 or how ever long it takes.

Please try your plan on a select cut.
 
Dockman, in case your wondering about the above comments, and since you siggy says still trying, I am gonna step across the line a let you know...

1. There are many of us who are concerned that people learning how to do brisket cooks successfully add to much to the process too soon, complicating the process and making success much harder to gain.

2. You are adding a lot of sugar to the surface of the meat with a soda pop marinade, this is going to cause over-darkening, if not downright burning of the meat. Often with a brisket, you will end up with a very hard bark as a result of too much sugar added.

3. Beyond just the time, cooking below 225F often leads to drying of the surface of the meat and to a hard and dry surface to the meat. Even though you can still end up with meat that is tender, it is often dry to the mouth. Some of us feel that going hotter aids in learning a successful cook.

4. Now why then, do we hear of other cooks saying such low temps and long cooks, there are two reasons, one if that they are cooking a lot of meat in big cookers, that just have a different way of cooking. Others are using a type of cooker, be it a water smoker or gas cooker, that has a moist air characteristic.

Still, it's your meat and I wish you luck with your cook. Your plan could work just fine. Be patient and make sure you get it cooked until tender to a probe.
 
Thank you for clearing up all the comments. Would love to try a easy marinate so any suggestions would be great.
Dockman, in case your wondering about the above comments, and since you siggy says still trying, I am gonna step across the line a let you know...

1. There are many of us who are concerned that people learning how to do brisket cooks successfully add to much to the process too soon, complicating the process and making success much harder to gain.

2. You are adding a lot of sugar to the surface of the meat with a soda pop marinade, this is going to cause over-darkening, if not downright burning of the meat. Often with a brisket, you will end up with a very hard bark as a result of too much sugar added.

3. Beyond just the time, cooking below 225F often leads to drying of the surface of the meat and to a hard and dry surface to the meat. Even though you can still end up with meat that is tender, it is often dry to the mouth. Some of us feel that going hotter aids in learning a successful cook.

4. Now why then, do we hear of other cooks saying such low temps and long cooks, there are two reasons, one if that they are cooking a lot of meat in big cookers, that just have a different way of cooking. Others are using a type of cooker, be it a water smoker or gas cooker, that has a moist air characteristic.

Still, it's your meat and I wish you luck with your cook. Your plan could work just fine. Be patient and make sure you get it cooked until tender to a probe.
 
Dockman, in case your wondering about the above comments, and since you siggy says still trying, I am gonna step across the line a let you know...

1. There are many of us who are concerned that people learning how to do brisket cooks successfully add to much to the process too soon, complicating the process and making success much harder to gain.

2. You are adding a lot of sugar to the surface of the meat with a soda pop marinade, this is going to cause over-darkening, if not downright burning of the meat. Often with a brisket, you will end up with a very hard bark as a result of too much sugar added.

3. Beyond just the time, cooking below 225F often leads to drying of the surface of the meat and to a hard and dry surface to the meat. Even though you can still end up with meat that is tender, it is often dry to the mouth. Some of us feel that going hotter aids in learning a successful cook.

4. Now why then, do we hear of other cooks saying such low temps and long cooks, there are two reasons, one if that they are cooking a lot of meat in big cookers, that just have a different way of cooking. Others are using a type of cooker, be it a water smoker or gas cooker, that has a moist air characteristic.

Still, it's your meat and I wish you luck with your cook. Your plan could work just fine. Be patient and make sure you get it cooked until tender to a probe.
You need a State Dept job:wink:
 
Thank you for clearing up all the comments. Would love to try a easy marinate so any suggestions would be great.

Some of the best briskets I've tasted were made without any marinade. The two absolute worst briskets I've tasted did use some type of marinade.
 
I don't marinade, or inject (unless I am messing around with competition techniques). But, if you simply must, use beef broth and the rub you are going to cook with. Just heat up a couple of cups of no salt or low salt beef broth, add in two tablespoons of rub. Cool completely and then marinate brisket in that overnight. It will add a little flavor, not much else. But, it won't screw anything up either.

Twas me, I would just rub it up tomorrow an hour before the cook.
 
Back
Top