Personally, I think there's too much variance in opinions about what is a "9" in any category (taste, tenderness, appearance) even among CBJs to really answer this question.
For instance, this box scored straight 9s on appearance earlier this year:
There's no way I'd have scored that a 9. The slices are ragged, the sauce is gloppy, and it's smeared on the box. I was appreciative and glad they did what they were supposed to and only judged the meat and not the messed up tangle of parsley that brackets it, but still, IMHO, this was NOT a 9 appearance box.
As for taste and tenderness, it was bland but juicy and slightly overcooked. All-in-all, not a great showing.:roll:
I just put it in here to point out that one man's ugly is another man's pretty. Same goes with flavor profiles. Even among CBJs.