My first brisket

Your rub sounds spot on. Inject if you like. Straight to UDS is fine. Going to depend on your temps. 4 to 8 hours will be my guess. A lot of people like to foil at 160. I've done it both ways. Get a better bark without foiling. Will finish faster with the foil.

At 8lbs, I am assuming it is just a flat?

I often mix hickory and pecan.

I like the rub combo, should work well. I prefer 275F to 300F and would look for being done around 4 hours. But, that is me, you might want to go more low-n-slow and try for 250F and 6 to 8 hours.

i dont know if my approach was right or wrong, but everybody loves it. i usually splash with worchester sauce and evoo then rub with my beef rub. i let it set in the cooler over night and take it out about 1-2 hours prior. get the pit set to about 190-200 and get it on. take it up to 160 where i put it in a foil pan and splash with worcherster and evoo (not alot, just enough to keep it from burning to the bottom of the pan) run it up too 190.

i have done this a day ahead and left it whole thing in the pan and just reheated back up to 160 or so again the next day, let it sit for an hour o so and then cut at half time, or when ever everybody else eats.:-D good luck.

i am doing about 4 or 5 5 lb chucks this weekend. i will use the same method and get about the same results as my brisket but i dont get the shrinkage and the price per pound was the same.

If it's just the flat, I would definately foil after 140 internal so it doesn't dry out. There really isn't much more smoke after it hits that temp, unless your pounding it with smoke.

moda253 said:

Skol Jimmy!

Click to expand...

SKOL brother!!!

Not to be disrespectful... how shall I put this? Do not follow the temp advice here on any type of beef, or pork for that matter.

Sorry If I offended you but I need to draw your attention to the fact I can just about guarantee that if anyone with any credibility says they make a GOOD brisket cooked at 200 degrees they are lying, or do not know what dry and tough means comparatively to a properly cooked brisket.

This Includes the "Legend."

Signed,

Popdaddy

jimmyinsd said:

i dont know if my approach was right or wrong, but everybody loves it. i usually splash with worchester sauce and evoo then rub with my beef rub. i let it set in the cooler over night and take it out about 1-2 hours prior. get the pit set to about 190-200 and get it on. take it up to 160 where i put it in a foil pan and splash with worcherster and evoo (not alot, just enough to keep it from burning to the bottom of the pan) run it up too 190.

i have done this a day ahead and left it whole thing in the pan and just reheated back up to 160 or so again the next day, let it sit for an hour o so and then cut at half time, or when ever everybody else eats.:-D good luck.

i am doing about 4 or 5 5 lb chucks this weekend. i will use the same method and get about the same results as my brisket but i dont get the shrinkage and the price per pound was the same.

Click to expand...

barbefunkoramaque said:

Not to be disrespectful... how shall I put this? Do not follow the temp advice here on any type of beef, or pork for that matter.

Sorry If I offended you but I need to draw your attention to the fact I can just about guarantee that if anyone with any credibility says they make a GOOD brisket cooked at 200 degrees they are lying, or do not know what dry and tough means comparatively to a properly cooked brisket.

This Includes the "Legend."

Signed,

Popdaddy

Click to expand...

none taken, but your tone was noted.:roll:

maybe my thermo is off but i have used this several times and i have not experienced a dry piece of meat yet. i have had both exceptional bbq, and crap that i wouldnt feed my dog so i think i have a pretty good idea about whats good or not. or maybe its a pallet thing, but like i said i have not had any complaints registered too date.

i am cooking on a cheap offset that tends to burn fast and hot so keeping the temps down are often a challenge, maybe i have been running hotter than my target more often than i thought. i now have an et-73 so we will see how this differs from the pit thermo temp.

This could be the case, I had a pit that no matter what therm I put on it, it read incredibly low. But once again, anyone who IS cooking their Brisket cooked at truly 200 degrees is making dried out Q. Maybe if they wrap it in foil most of the way or have an EXTREMELY tight pit bordering on a vacuum chamber. Furthermore, for the cooking part (not ring set) zilch happens to brisket under 212.... zilch, (well over a god damn long time maybe something will) and I can count of three hands the restaurants I have advised that did not heed my warning and have since gone out of business because for "timing issues" they chose to smoke at 215, 212, 200.

I have also seen my share of people on this forum and others that have tried the Night Train Experiment (especially those north of the belt) who come to a realization that their palette was the victim of local inexperience.

The tone you notice was one of a guy who knows what the common pitfalls are of people who think they know how to make Q. And, we have all, everyone in this forum, have served our share of crap to those who would never complain.

Nothing at all personal. If I sound like an asshole then add "good judge of people" to your list of skills. :-D

jimmyinsd said:

none taken, but your tone was noted.:roll:

maybe my thermo is off but f thhave used this several times and i have not experienced a dry piece of meat yet. i have had both exceptional bbq, and crap that i wouldnt feed my dog so i think i have a pretty good idea about whats good or not. or maybe its a pallet thing, but like i said i have not had any complaints registered too date.

i am cooking on a cheap offset that tends to burn fast and hot so keeping the temps down are often a challenge, maybe i have been running hotter than my target more often than i thought. i now have an et-73 so we will see how this differs from the pit thermo temp.

Click to expand...

Popdaddy,

Vicious,
You hit me with a flower,
You do it every hour,
Oh, baby, you're so vicious!

barbefunkoramaque said:

This could be the case, I had a pit that no matter what therm I put on it, it read incredibly low. But once again, anyone who IS cooking their Brisket cooked at truly 200 degrees is making dried out Q. Maybe if they wrap it in foil most of the way or have an EXTREMELY tight pit bordering on a vacuum chamber. Furthermore, for the cooking part (not ring set) zilch happens to brisket under 212.... zilch, (well over a god damn long time maybe something will) and I can count of three hands the restaurants I have advised that did not heed my warning and have since gone out of business because for "timing issues" they chose to smoke at 215, 212, 200.

I have also seen my share of people on this forum and others that have tried the Night Train Experiment (especially those north of the belt) who come to a realization that their palette was the victim of local inexperience.

The tone you notice was one of a guy who knows what the common pitfalls are of people who think they know how to make Q. And, we have all, everyone in this forum, have served our share of crap to those who would never complain.

Nothing at all personal. If I sound like an asshole then add "good judge of people" to your list of skills. :-D

Click to expand...

I like your style but your comments are useless unless you inform us on what should be done. enlighten me!

Johnny_Crunch said:

I like your style but your comments are useless unless you inform us on what should be done. enlighten me!

Click to expand...

A first time brisket cook could glean a lot of insight and wisdom from the channelled one of Popdaddy. The man rambles( Pitmaster DonnieT), but he has cooked his share of brisket, and knows of which he speaks. Wisdom comes from experience, and long nights tending a stick burner. i enjoy the musing of the once misplaced Texan, and his quest for bbq nurvana. Preach on brother Donnie T, we await your words of wisdom.:thumb:

Johnny_Crunch said:

I like your style but your comments are useless unless you inform us on what should be done. enlighten me!

Click to expand...

well the reason why i didn't is you could throw a stone and hit a good recipe round here. Heck, I think Land Arc nailed one and it ain't my way of doing it neither.

I am just saying... 200 degrees, you are gonna almost universally **** the **** up.

Okay I'll jump in. There are so many factors to consider, this question is difficult to answer but I'll try. Long but hopefully helpful!

Brisket is the hardest to cook well for a reason - depending on the cut your using you have differing amounts of marbling and different thicknesses. A choice or CAB brisket bought at Sam's for instance is usually a whole packer with the point (and fat layer between) removed then cut in half - there is very little fat in this cut to keep things moist through a long cook. A big old well marbled 13 to 15# whole packer is still difficult to cook well but I think a little more forgiving because of the fat content.

We learned the hard way cooking too low and too slow and ended up with dry brisket every time. We started cranking up the temps even trying "fast & hot" a couple times with success but have settled into a successful groove keeping grate temp near but not below 250 with 275 as a high point.

Cook temp and time is also rather smoker specific. Like Pop said, you could probably get away with that low a temp (but why) if you had a really tight smoker like a Jambo that stayed at temp with very little air flow. Running a el cheapo leaky offset (high air flow) at a low temp will dry out a brisket in no time. On our 22 WSM's (which I would rank a 7 out of 10 for tightness) we use full simmering water pans so we have a lot of moisture in the system (which helps immensely) with moderate air flow.

So Moda a quick guideline to try (if you haven't already given it a go) with the cut you mention - sounds like a flat. Fire and smoke - good starting point for smoke level - embed 2 or 3 fist size chunks of your favorite hard/fruit wood in pile of unlit charcoal - 1 starter of lit on top - allow to burn in and spark off any dust, white smoke should die down signaling a clean burn - 2 to 3 chunks on top right before placing grate - top vent should always remain full open - bottom vents full open to start. Get a cheap oven thermometer and place it in the middle of the grate. Preheat your UDS to a grate temp of 250 (if you place it in the right spot after your meat is placed you can use a flashlight to see the grate temp through the top vent w/o opening) adjusting bottom vents as needed. Your spice rub blend is actually very traditional and simple and should work nicely - injecting beef broth can't hurt either but I would let the meat rest a bit after injecting so it can distribute then add the rub which with the injection becomes more of a wet rub - will dissolve in nicely into meat. I typically massage in one layer of rub then add a second sprinkled from a shaker so the rub sits proud of the meat - helps create a nice bark. I am a big fan of water smokers and water pans so I would recommend if your not using one in your UDS to use an aluminum pan full of water. Fill it back up when you change/add charcoal. Not going to give you times but we find at 250 in our WSM's BB is about an hour a pound pulling at 195 in the thickest part of the flat. Don't worry about probing temp for a few hours just let it cook and no peaking - hopefully you can see your grate thermo. After 3 or 4 hours take a look at where your color is and bark formation - go ahead and insert a leave-in meat thermo or probe. The finished color I like is a deep mahogany verging on black with streaks that are almost golden in color. My technique requires tenting loosely before this color is reached because I open it back up for the last hour to set the bark. Unless you have hungry guests and need to speed things up or just can't seem to maintain moisture I don't foil tightly. If you have large enough foil pans (otherwise make a boat out of HDAF) place the meat in the pan which will capture juices then loosely tent with HDAF to hold the color and smoke level. Keep cooking! If your not sure when your about an hour out then pull the tent around 185 internal - leave in pan. The spice blend will mellow over the length of the cook so if you like a nice salty peppery kick balanced by a nice beefy interior then sprinkle a modest third layer of your rub right after pulling the tent. Cook until an internal of 195 (temp will rise another 5 degrees or so while resting. If serving immediately place on a butcher block and let rest for 10 to 15 minutes in the open before slicing and serving. If you need to hold a little longer you can again tent loosely - don't slice until your ready to serve! The drippings are full of flavor and depending on how much rendered can be used straight or added to broth to make an au jus. Enjoy!

Disclaimer: Some portions or steps of this technique have been withheld to protect the innocent aka the above I think is a good starting point. Additions, subtractions, thoughts are certainly welcome as the learning process is never-ending.

Good luck with your first brisket. Let us know how it turns/turned out!

barbefunkoramaque said:

This could be the case, I had a pit that no matter what therm I put on it, it read incredibly low. But once again, anyone who IS cooking their Brisket cooked at truly 200 degrees is making dried out Q. Maybe if they wrap it in foil most of the way or have an EXTREMELY tight pit bordering on a vacuum chamber. Furthermore, for the cooking part (not ring set) zilch happens to brisket under 212.... zilch, (well over a god damn long time maybe something will) and I can count of three hands the restaurants I have advised that did not heed my warning and have since gone out of business because for "timing issues" they chose to smoke at 215, 212, 200.

I have also seen my share of people on this forum and others that have tried the Night Train Experiment (especially those north of the belt) who come to a realization that their palette was the victim of local inexperience.

The tone you notice was one of a guy who knows what the common pitfalls are of people who think they know how to make Q. And, we have all, everyone in this forum, have served our share of crap to those who would never complain.

Nothing at all personal. If I sound like an asshole then add "good judge of people" to your list of skills. :-D

Click to expand...

Poppdaddy, i had too check it out and i guess we are both correct. i however have given some bad advice unless somebody happens to be using the same crappy set up i am.

i set up the el cheapo offset as usual and when my maverik read 230 at middle of the pit i read the thermo at the far end and it read....195. the firebox side read about 260.:shock:

i guess i was doing it right, just not reporting it very well. i used 190 on that end because when i first got the thing i would do ribs that were always tuff if i let the far end get over 200-210.

Moda, sorry if you took my poor advice, (we will have to get together some time too talk football, and i will buy you a replacement brisket)

Popps...please dont take this as me stroking your ego, cuz i think you do a good enough job stroking yourself. j/k brother:-D keep it low and slow..... but not too low :wink::redface: