WB, Send Meghan at KJ an email and they'll take care of you. I've seen this happen on other Kamado brands as well including the Komado, Primo and BGE's.
Sometimes you get gaskets with adhesive bonding issues. My friend tore his gasket off his BGE on the first burn. Good news is both KJ and BGE take care of clients when this does occur.
You'll still be able to grill in the meantime just not low and slow or easily over 600F. Just make sure to remove any left over fuzz so you don't trap more grease gunk between the gaskets that will make it harder to put on a replacement set.
Goo-off adhesive remover works very well without any scraping.
Super fast Red Themapen, Weber Platinum, Kamado Joe Big Joe, Maverick ET-732