Originally Posted by kds9547
Cooked my first one Thursday night (actually cooked two). I seasoned one with fresh ground S&P and the other with a Santa Maria rub. I put the rub on that morning and placed them back in the fridge. Took them out and placed on the counter 1 hour before going on the BGE. I cooked them at 275 on my adjustable rig (with heat diverter) and removed when they hit 110* and foiled. Brought the egg up to 700* and seared a couple minutes on each side and they were pretty awesome. Four guys ate 5.5lbs of tri-tip and none left. I will definitely do this again.
I had to order mine from a local butcher and it was 8.99 a lb. I need to find another source.
Here at my local butcher, I've seen them on sale three different occasions over the past 4 or 5 months for $3.99/lb.
18.5" WSM, Hasty-Bake Suburban, OTG 22.5", "Antonio" Bandera, Mini WSM