Originally Posted by SLCMACK
It has a little spotchy rust on the firebox
Oh man! That thing is worthless! I'll do you a favor and come take it off your hands.
Honestly, the rule of thumb for used stuff is usually 50% - 60% of original purchase price after a year or so depending on condition. However, with a Peoria, I bet there's high demand for something in good condition. You could probably ask a little more than 60% of original price.