The rule can either be written in such a way so as to remove ALL possibility of anyone putting a spin on it, or we can just continue debating this forever. It DOES NOT matter if the rule is clear cut black and white, which I happen to think it is. The fact is that as it is it can be twisted by those who wish to do so. Nobody in this thread wants to do that, so I'm obviously not referring to anyone involved in this thread.
My whole point in this thread is that the wording needs to be sewed up so tight that there are no possible loopholes. Otherwise this debate will never die, and I think that most of us want it to.