When you buy butts, there are 2 in a pack. Did the 2 pieces possibly just separate, and you thought it was one piece?
Twisted Brisket BBQ Team - CBJ
Disposables By STARK
Disposable Cutting Boards on a Perforated Roll, 5 gl Bucket Liners, Steam Pan Liners, Cooler Liners, Stark Naked BBQ Pit, Probe & Grill Stripper