Well, I'm definitely a thin crust guy, so that narrows it down. I definitely have a preference for traditional toppings, so that again narrows it down. I have no doubt Bob's crust was good, but I have no idea what the toppings were. Buccaneer, you were most definitely in the running, but you lost me with your choice of toppings.
Sooooo.....I've narrowed it down to boogiesnap, and myself. It would be far too east to vote for myself, but I know how awesome it tasted.