Sounds like you covered all the usual problems....I never had to use a water pan. I have one 3/4" pipe open and one ball valve opened half way. As the meat cooks and temp. rises i close the ball valve accordingly.
BTW. I use B&B lump. the temps are more controllable with it..
Sent from my GS3 via Tapatalk 2
The SIZZL says when it's done...